T205 American Beauty Back Question

[tedzan]

Andrew

Since I am being accused of "de-railing" this thread....I will try to get it back on track.
My records indicate that the T205 Ty Cobb card is available with these 6 backs.........

AMERICAN BEAUTY Factory 42

HASSAN Factory 30

HONEST Long Cut

PIEDMONT Factory 25

PIEDMONT Factory 42

POLAR BEAR


Can you (or anyone here) account for any other backs that the Cobb is found with ?


TED Z

[Wite3]

Ted,
Those are the six backs that Cobb comes with and have been confirmed by my research (meaning, I own one, held one or have seen very clear scans of one).

I will tell you that a T205 Cobb will most likely never occur with a Hassan 649 back. It is in a grouping of cards that is not found with that particular back. Hassan 649 backs are also common, not like a Hindu or Broadleaf card from either T206 or T205. One certainly would have been seen by now. Is it impossible...not at all since new finds are popping up all the time but I stand by my theory and research.

Incidentally...the cards that fall into Cobb's grouping tend to be several of the cards that were replaced or switched in later print runs. T205 print runs are far more complicated than T206 print runs with certain cards being switched out, fixed, eliminated and added.

Joshua

[asoriano]

If we are counting blank backs, Cobb also exists with that particular reverse.

[Abravefan11]

Originally Posted by Wite3

I will tell you that a T205 Cobb will most likely never occur with a Hassan 649 back. It is in a grouping of cards that is not found with that particular back.

Joshua

Joshua - Approximately how many cards are in the group that was not printed with Hassan 649 backs? And how many were printed with this back? Thanks.

[tedzan]

Joshua

Thanks for the confirmation of the 6 back versions of the T205 Cobb. HASSAN Factory #649 cards are common
enough that a Cobb would have surfaced by now....had it been printed.

I put this set together in the early 1990's, and paid close attention to the Cobb's. Nothing beats the empirically
gained knowledge gleaned from years of collecting these cards.

Best regards,

TED Z

[Leon]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Joshua
Nothing beats the empirically
gained knowledge gleaned from years of collecting these cards.

Best regards,

TED Z

Except empirically gained knowledge gleaned from years of collecting these cards by hundreds/thousands of collectors uniting for the benefit of the whole community.

[tedzan]

DITTO....kiddo


In the process of completing a 211-card set (including Hoblitzell -- No Stats), I interfaced with at least 40 other collectors buying, trading,
and sharing info on T205's.


TED Z

[bbeck]

Originally Posted by tedzan

Joshua

Thanks for the confirmation of the 6 back versions of the T205 Cobb. HASSAN Factory #649 cards are common
enough that a Cobb would have surfaced by now....had it been printed.

I put this set together in the early 1990's, and paid close attention to the Cobb's. Nothing beats the empirically
gained knowledge gleaned from years of collecting these cards.

Best regards,

TED Z

Ted-I have a question since you have done extensive research on the t205 set. Who, in your opinion, is the toughest Hall of Fame member with a confirmed American Beauty back and how does Rube Marquard stack up as far as scarcity regarding the back?-thank you -Bob

[tedzan]

I don't claim to be an expert on this set. I completed it many years ago. I sold it back in 1997 to one of the guys here on Net54.
In the process, I did keep track of the T205 Ty Cobb's.

Joshua is the Net54 resident T205 expert.


TED Z

Originally Posted by bbeck

Ted-I have a question since you have done extensive research on the t205 set. Who, in your opinion, is the toughest Hall of Fame member with a confirmed American Beauty back and how does Rube Marquard stack up as far as scarcity regarding the back?-thank you -Bob

Matty by far

[Wite3]

I would have to agree with Andrew on the relative rarity of Matty with American Beauty...not because it was printed less but because of the demand.

Tim,
You question is fairly complex. There are more than one grouping of cards printed with and without Hassan 649 backs.

One grouping is the Minor League cards with come with 649 backs but not 30 backs...I would put this as the group that most likely replaced the cards like Cobb.

There is also a grouping that contains some of the variations and single prints (Kleinow, Grant, Wallace no cap, etc.)

Then there are ones that defy explanation like Matty or Olmstead which seems like they should come with the 649 back but I have not confirmed it yet.

I can tell you that as of now my research shows that I have confirmed 77 different cards that come with the Hassan 649 back.

I can also say I have seen 95 different cards that come with the Hassan 30 back.

There are 53 confirmed with both backs.

I feel that this list is still incomplete though.

I hope this helps a bit.

Joshua