PSA slabs a Hank Aaron reprint

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by brewing

That Mack Cracker Jack has my vote for biggest mistake.

Originally Posted by 4815162342

The T206 Heinie that was slabbed a Honus gets my vote. I wish I would’ve saved a scan years ago when it was for sale on eBay.

I still vote for the PSA 8 Wagner as the worst.

[nat]

It's weird; except for the novelty bidders, this is an auction for money. The PSA guarantee is worth far more than a reprint, so, again, unless you're doing it for the novelty factor, the thing to do if you win this auction is to call in the PSA guarantee (assuming that they honor it). Which means that you should expect the auction to end at whatever the guarantee for this card is.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by nat

It's weird; except for the novelty bidders, this is an auction for money. The PSA guarantee is worth far more than a reprint, so, again, unless you're doing it for the novelty factor, the thing to do if you win this auction is to call in the PSA guarantee (assuming that they honor it). Which means that you should expect the auction to end at whatever the guarantee for this card is.

As a novelty bidder I pushed it to the current price. $20 shipped for a cool PSA error was my limit as I had no plans for trying to get PSA to honor anything.

[aconte]

Originally Posted by nat

It's weird; except for the novelty bidders, this is an auction for money. The PSA guarantee is worth far more than a reprint, so, again, unless you're doing it for the novelty factor, the thing to do if you win this auction is to call in the PSA guarantee (assuming that they honor it). Which means that you should expect the auction to end at whatever the guarantee for this card is.

The guarantee is out the window on mechanical label errors which is what they
will claim.

[Tabe]

Originally Posted by bnorth

I still vote for the PSA 8 Wagner as the worst.

It ain't a mistake if it is intentional