Should these 3 players be in the HOF

[G1911]

I completely understand why some people think he should be forgiven, but I cannot fathom how some people do not understand (or pretend not to understand to stir the pot) why Rose is banned. It was the number 1 rule in baseball, the stakes were known, he obviously and provably broke that rule. Duh.

[Tabe]

Gaylord Perry and David Ortiz are in. Clemens and Bonds should be.

Rose is an easy no. He broke the cardinal rule.

[rand1com]

Originally Posted by G1911

I completely understand why some people think he should be forgiven, but I cannot fathom how some people do not understand (or pretend not to understand to stir the pot) why Rose is banned. It was the number 1 rule in baseball, the stakes were known, he obviously and provably broke that rule. Duh.

So true!! Nothing else needs to be said.

[steve B]

What's odd is that the hobby conveniently also forgets Rose selling multiple bats related to the same milestone hit on the way to the record. Not the major ones, but stuff like two people with bats from like hit 4187.