Moral of story: don't sell an altered card. Sorry that I have to out a fellow member.

[Tcards-Please]

So how many of you are going to go after that T206 Honus Wagner that is being talked about on another thread? It's a good deal right now as PSA could be wrong. How many of you would have asked the seller (if he didn't already disclose the fact that the authenticity was questionable by PSA), "if this doesn't grade a minimum of Authentic, can I return it?" That question gets asked ALOT. Suppose the flip had "AUTHENTIC/ALTERED" how many of you would now bid on that card? So for all the lip on TPG, most (not all) of you would take a leap of faith with their assessment as opposed to taking someones word especially when their feedback is 96.7%.

Again, I'm not saying one person's assessment is wrong and that TPG are the be all in making determinations on the characteristics of a card.

No witch hunt here, all I'm saying is why not disclose the information you have on hand so that potential buyers can make an informed decision?

And I'm sure Jim is a good guy.