I would say that I have always been on the fence on this card. On any given day I’ve sway more towards a regional promotional issue or give away item. The fact that Russell had one from GA and Cobb being the Georgia Peach seemed a little convenient. Also the other finds I think for the most part have been down south correct? Then the find with the multiples a lot of these situations seem not so T206 in my eyes.
But then there are the striking similarities and as Barry said without a smoking gun, its home in T206 is as good as any.
Also not making it a T206 doesn’t help the checklist on completion of the T206 set much easier. In fact this card is more obtainable in regards to price and availability than Wagner and Doyle. Now if we can agree Wagner and Doyle are not T206’s perhaps I can finish the set next year.