Comparing a cards scarcity/rarity to a T206 Wagner

[ricktmd]

The Collins batting t206 proof must have incredible value these days

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by ricktmd

The Collins batting t206 proof must have incredible value these days

That Collins is a total dream card of mine. This one is not a bad consolation (although the Collins crushes the Matty), and likely meets the rarity/scarcity thing

[Yoda]

Lew Lipset once told me that he thought the E90-1 Speaker was tougher than the Mitchell.

[mrreality68]

Some nice cards shown thanks

And great thread and dialogue

[Pat R]

Originally Posted by ricktmd

The Collins batting t206 proof must have incredible value these days

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

That Collins is a total dream card of mine. This one is not a bad consolation (although the Collins crushes the Matty), and likely meets the rarity/scarcity thing

These are two examples of why I posted the thread, it's not about whether a card is rare it's about when someone compares a card to the T206 Wagner. For it to be as equal a comparison as it can be you need to compare that cards scarcity in the set it is in to how scarce the Wagner is in the T206 set.

The Collins wouldn't be a fair comparison because it's not in the set and the Matty should only be compared as a White cap Matty.