Which Red T206 Cobb Would You Rather Have?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by sycks22

Any pictures?

Sorry about that. The last thread I had to delete as it wasn't allowing me to add the poll. They are here now.

[3-2-count]

Hi Leon. I’d easily choose the 1.5 over the 4, hands down!

[mrreality68]

I like the centering and the corners on the 1.5

I would take either but if I had to choose the 1.5 would be the first choice

[RCFire82]

Not a fan of the diamond cut...but the 1.5 corners almost look trimmed imho

[Bobbycee]

Tough call. I really dislike T206's in that darn baggie. It's annoying & takes away from the eye appeal. The 1.5 is a nicer looking card, but I'd rather have a 4 for my collection despite the badly off center/cut card.

[DeanH3]

Easy for me. 1.5 all day long.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Bobbycee

Tough call. I really dislike T206's in that darn baggie. It's annoying & takes away from the eye appeal. The 1.5 is a nicer looking card, but I'd rather have a 4 for my collection despite the badly off center/cut card.

Further expanding on this, since you feel the 1.5 is better looking, it's a monetary thing? And that is why I framed the question the way I did. As of now exactly 1/3 of our members agree with you. So there is some company in your camp.
.

[Bobbycee]

Originally Posted by Leon

Further expanding on this, since you feel the 1.5 is better looking, it's a monetary thing? And that is why I framed the question the way I did. As of now exactly 1/3 of our members agree with you. So there is some company in your camp.
.

If, say, I'm putting together a T206 set in a PSA 3-4, I'd rather have the 4. If, I just wanted to add a great card of an all time great, I'd rather have the 1.5. If I had $4,000, and wanted a Cobb, I'd happily grab the 1.5, rather than save to buy the 4.