Best lefty off all time? My vote is Koufax!

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by Snowman

I couldn't have possibly been more clear and consistent throughout this entire thread that I've only ever been interested in someone's peak 4 or 5 years when trying to figure out who I think was best. Your bad faith arguments are getting tiresome.

Then why did you justify ignoring Koufax' first 5 years on a different basis?
I think it's more than fair to give him a pass while he tried to figure things out. Your words.
Yes. I ignore Koufax's early years. He was a teenager when he entered the league. Your words.

You would have the same exact assessment if his career had gone in reverse. Again, that's fine, but your excuses for him are pretextual.

Bad faith indeed.