SGC mistake :-(

[ullmandds]

Unfortunately mistakes do occur. Similar thing happened to me with a high grade e106 I sent in to SGC...came back A...I sold it...they resent...came back like a 6 I think. I was pissed. Life goes on.

Sadly with many buying only slabbed cards there's no way one can become versed at detecting alterations when a card is in a slab!

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

Unfortunately mistakes do occur. Similar thing happened to me with a high grade e106 I sent in to SGC...came back A...I sold it...they resent...came back like a 6 I think. I was pissed. Life goes on.

Sadly with many buying only slabbed cards there's no way one can become versed at detecting alterations when a card is in a slab!

Couldn't happen to a nicer guy.....And you still love SGC right Pete? I know sending it to PSA was not an option even though there's potential double or triple resale value....

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

Couldn't happen to a nicer guy.....And you still love SGC right Pete? I know sending it to PSA was not an option even though there's potential double or triple resale value....

Interesting considering it was just pointed out that PSA made the exact same error on the Wallace.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by Gobucsmagic74

Interesting considering it was just pointed out that PSA made the exact same error on the Wallace.

Not at all Dan, PSA is human as well, absolutely. What I get sick and tired of is hearing about how great SGC is on this forum, how corrupt PSA is, and most of the SGC supporters say, "I love the SGC holders (really?), they are more consistant than PSA, and I dont care about resale value, just the card... Really? How much sense does that make? What percentage of members on this board value their money? Answer....100%.

[chalupacollects]

I may be wrong but couldn't you at one time have had a card slabbed as authentic only without paying extra for the numerical grade? This may be a case where original slabber did that to save a few bucks and just protect the card...

[swarmee]

You still have the ability to declare "slab as authentic" even if it makes a number grade, but I don't think the submitters of these cards would have done that. These are not cards to be ashamed of and label as authentic instead of giving a number.

[Thecafewha]

Originally Posted by swarmee

You still have the ability to declare "slab as authentic" even if it makes a number grade, but I don't think the submitters of these cards would have done that. These are not cards to be ashamed of and label as authentic instead of giving a number.

You’d be surprised how different people view lower grades versus a nice looking slabbed authentic card. It would be interesting to know from the flip if it was assigned a A or the A was chosen by the submitter.

I have purchased a few PSA A cards that were purposely slabbed without a numeric grade. I have resubmitted 3 and all 3 received a numeric grade (although they were lower grade Venezuela Topps).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Leon]

Many times lower grade cards aren't slabbed as they bring more money raw..
..in hopes of high(er) grades that they really aren't .

Originally Posted by Thecafewha

You’d be surprised how different people view lower grades versus a nice looking slabbed authentic card. It would be interesting to know from the flip if it was assigned a A or the A was chosen by the submitter.

I have purchased a few PSA A cards that were purposely slabbed without a numeric grade. I have resubmitted 3 and all 3 received a numeric grade (although they were lower grade Venezuela Topps).


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk