Cards loose inside SGC holders?

[Ronnie73]

I've had cards in SGC holders get between the black insert and the plastic case. After tapping the card loose, it usually shows some edge damage such as a thin layer of the cardboard rolled or lifted up. Seems all holder types have their flaws but BVG tends to keep cards secure and damage free.

[iwantitiwinit]

Got 10 t206's back from SGC a few weeks ago, had the same problem with 4 of them. It was clear the black inserts were too small haven"t gotten around to contacting them but something is up. If those inserts are precut from a supplier they def. shorted them.

[dog*dirt]

My last two submissions had cards that looked like this, a total of 8 that were loose, 5 cards I could tap back in place and 3 cards I could not.

[glchen]

I agree that Beckett has the best holders in terms of securing the card and preventing float or the insert from damaging the edges of the cards.

[4815162342]

http://www.net54baseball.com/showthr...28#post1012328

[Ronnie73]

It seems that the black insert thickness is less lately which is allowing alot of the newer submissions to come back with the cards all over the place. Whats worse is you win an auction and the scan shows the card nice and centered in the holder and after bouncing around from shipping, its all sideways in the holder. Happened to me when I won a T206 Hal Chase Sovereign 460 Blue Portrait SGC 60. What a shock when I opened the package .

[tiger8mush]

Originally Posted by glchen

I agree that Beckett has the best holders in terms of securing the card and preventing float or the insert from damaging the edges of the cards.

+1

Beckett's holder is also tougher to break into. While there have been evidence of SGC and PSA cases being tampered with - like taking out the originally graded card and slipping in a new one of lower quality) I don't recall ever seeing a BVG tampered with.

[CobbSpikedMe]

This would annoy me to no end if I got a card and it was out of it's place in the slab.

Can't you send it back to SGC and have them re-holder it for free in cases like this?

Thanks,

AndyH

[npa589]

Recent submissions for me have had the same problem, 50% of them.

Their batch of holders, as someone else has suggested, may have been a tiny bit short!