Goodwin Auction Pick Ups / Prices

[Blunder19]

Anyone get some nice cards from the goodwin?

Was it just me... or did the T206 rare backs go for very good deals?

SGC20 BL460 under $2400

PSA 4 Drum $2600

Not sure why the PSA 1 Red Hindu sold for almost as much as the SGC 10 Red Hindu... I would much rather have the SGC10 one...

Any thoughts on this?

[wonkaticket]

No doubt I think we need to adjust some prices when it comes to backs.

It's very clear to see that BL460 is not pulling the coin it once was.

REA and now Goodwin seem to show that...in fact it was a good thing I needed the Murphy I bought for my back set recently. I can perhaps justify the overpayment as I clearly paid way more than market value based upon the same grade card going off in Goodwin for way less than I paid. No complaints though happy with my purchase and it was for my back run etc.

However if I was in the market for another BL460 I would have to take into consideration the past auction results.

Drum is on the rise and I don’t think Uzit would be far behind Drum today.

As for the PSA 4 Drum in Goodwin...I'm shocked that card is a 4 that is one ugly 4 IMO.

All of this flips sides over the years in another 3 years Drum will be down and perhaps BL460 is crazy again. With that said as of today it seems to be BL460 is a bit soft.

Cheers,

John

P.S. I guess SGC didn’t review the Brown Old Mill Dolly Stark in time or it wasn’t a Brown Old Mill?

[Michael Peich]

Guys--I don't know if this is the correct thread for my request (Leon/Brian move me if I'm OT here), but if the winner(s) of the Emmerke, Patton and Phelan OJs have dupes they would like to sell, I'm interested, and please email me at mpeich@comcast.net.

The final price on Patton was quite strong, to say the least.

Thanks, Mike

[tbob]

I managed to snag this E98 Vaughn, 2nd highest ever graded. I am trying to complete a red background E98 set since Scott's already got the complete green one

[philliesphan]

was very happy to grab this:

[rman444]

I picked up this c1900's cabinet of Tinker. It is the image used for his T206 Hands on Knees pose - thought it was pretty cool!

[M's_Fan]

I picked up a few T205 St. Louis players that I think went for decent prices. $284 for the Huggins and $235 for the Bresnahan. I was the only bidder on the Bresnahan.

[JP]

Originally Posted by wonkaticket

As for the PSA 4 Drum in Goodwin...I'm shocked that card is a 4 that is one ugly 4 IMO.

I bought the Drum. I think the scan didn't do the card justice. I have almost purchased that card on two separate occasions from Scott over the past few years, but never got around to pulling the trigger. The card is most definitely better than a 3...probably deserves a 3.5. I'll post higher res scans so you can see once I receive it. Overgraded or not, I still think I got a heck of a deal getting it at PSA 2 prices.