Psa,bgs,sgc

[Theoldprofessor]

Originally Posted by glchen

I use all three, but more of my cards are in PSA. As mentioned above, all three are accurate in determining authenticity of cards and alterations ...

WHAT??!! Ask the guy whose Plank was butchered before being slabbed as "Mr. X" by PSA at a grade of 4 if he thinks all three are "accurate ... in determining alterations." Bet he'd say no. In fact, I know he would.

[travrosty]

Originally Posted by Theoldprofessor

WHAT??!! Ask the guy whose Plank was butchered before being slabbed as "Mr. X" by PSA at a grade of 4 if he thinks all three are "accurate ... in determining alterations." Bet he'd say no. In fact, I know he would.

agreed

[Donscards]

I use both---but prefer SGC for the vintage--pre 1910---especially Mayo's---I feel SGC is more acurate right now on the grading---PSA is being extremely tough on cards right now( I feel they do not want to give the 8's and 9's to the vintage--due to the registry and the more they give the higher grades--the values come down which they dont want)---I am holding back on PSA as to submitting at this time--maybe PSA will come back to earth. Don

[travrosty]

Originally Posted by Donscards

I use both---but prefer SGC for the vintage--pre 1910---especially Mayo's---I feel SGC is more acurate right now on the grading---PSA is being extremely tough on cards right now( I feel they do not want to give the 8's and 9's to the vintage--due to the registry and the more they give the higher grades--the values come down which they dont want)---I am holding back on PSA as to submitting at this time--maybe PSA will come back to earth. Don

unless you are a celebrity or athlete, then they put your name on the label.