Goodwin Auction is open + Peck & Snyder Discussion

[terjung]

A small, but really impressive auction!

[slidekellyslide]

Will be fun to watch that Tango Eggs Cobb...any guesses on a the hammer price?

[Delray Vintage]

Bill he's some terrific items particularly the Harry wright 172 and delahanty cards

[oldjudge]

The auction does have some great cards, but the Wright is not one of them. An Old Judge with a badly faded photo is nothing to get excited about, regardless of the technical grade.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

The auction does have some great cards, but the Wright is not one of them. An Old Judge with a badly faded photo is nothing to get excited about, regardless of the technical grade.

Looks like it's mis-cut at the bottom as well, or was that common for OJ's? Shouldn't that affect the grade?

[oldjudge]

Having an angular cut is not particularily unusual. The card's problem is the photo, not the cut. For photo clarity, the most important factor when judging Old Judge cards, it is a 2, not an 8.

[felada]

The peck and snyder is interesting. There are two distinct types for the Cinci card. While both are typically dated 1869 is the general consensus that the type offered in the auction was issued earlier than the other type?