What is the long-term value of Game-Used cards?

[Republicaninmass]

close your eyes what do you see....

They are kinda neat, other than a novelty not quite sure

[Exhibitman]

Some points on a lazy Thursday afternoon:

--Whether or not modern GU/Auto cards are appealing depends in part on whether you like and follow the current game and want to collect something from it. If so, you obviously cannot collect vintage cards of modern players. For me, I try to pick up autographed modern cards of players I enjoy watching, like Jeter or Ichiro, and if I see a GU card that I find appealing I might pick it up too if it is cheap. When I had a chance to go behind the scenes at Dodgers Stadium some years ago I picked up a bunch of modern GU cards for my nephew and I to get autographed by some of the players we liked.

--Orioles1954, you are right and wrong. Some posters are not especially tactful in their responses and some posts do 'diss' modern cards for reasons that have little relationship to the question the original poster raised. However, you may also consider that there is a difference between criticizing a collector for collecting and criticizing the item being collected. Many people here loathe the practice of cutting up jerseys and bats to make cards with little chips of jerseys and bats on them. Their expressions of their disgust for the practice is not personal; don't take it that way. Also, the thread was opinions on the long-term value of GU cards, and there I think the posters discounting the potential future appreciation of those cards based on performance over the last decade or so have good points.

As is often remarked on this site, collect what you want. Just don't take others' negative opinions of what you collect to heart. Life it too short to worry about what other people think. Besides, we all spend countless hours playing with baseball cards. We're all dipsh**s.

[Rich Klein]

Like I said; I'm literally on both sides of the aisle here ---- more than most of you realize and frankly I'm more aware of the modern card market than I am of the vintage card market many times


A few longer bullet-points: I've posted most of these thoughts one way or the other in the past.

** In 2002, I gave a presentation at the first "Deadball" conference in Hot Springs, Ark. Mike D was not yet part of the group otherwise he would have been part of the "spirited" discussion. We were all expected to bring research topics to the table -- and with my lack of time to prepare -- I went a slightly different way and began a conversation about deadball era BB Cards and why did 1910 seem to be the key year.
During that discussion, I brought up the concept of game-used cards and you have to remember that was the concept of vintage players and game-used was still a reasonably new concept. It was also a good target audience in that none of the other six people there were really active collectors -- except for me having to chase down a Dave Egan card. (You had to be there to understand why).
We basically agreed, that if a player had used hundreds of bats during his career; that cutting up 1-2 of them for cards was not neccessarily a bad idea BUT if you had a situation such as In the Game cutting up the only known pair of Georges Vezina pads then you had a terrrible disservice to history. The middle is broad; but at the time, most of the card companies actually tried to keep track and if they knew it was the only one, they usually passed on cutting.

***** In today's world, collectors expect to get at least one "hit" (which in these terms mean autographs or memorabilia) out of every box. In some products the cards are of vintage players and thus the memorabilia is the same. ****

**** So far, and I would suspect in the future -- autograph cards have and will continue to hold their value better than game-used cards. As always there are exceptions, one of which is the 2001 SP Legendary Cuts Joe Jackson bat card. There will be no more Joe Jackson "game-used' bat cards issued by a licensed manufacturer unless he gets reinstated. Other non-licensced companies can used Shoeless Joe.

***** Sometimes, as has been pointed out, these cards *DO* generate interest in vintage cards and cards and more of these players can be the gateway to vintage cards. The same has been true of the Topps "Million Card Giveaway" which has spurred several people *I* have "spoken to on FB* to start collecting older cards. I know of one collector who now buys 5-10 small lots of pre-1970 cards on EBay each week and I'll bet he goes back into our cards soon


***** And if we want future collectors to have the same love for these old cards that we do, let's not diss them at this point. Just because *I* was able to buy my 1st T-Cards in the mid-1970's for $1-2 each including HOFers -- does not mean the same runs true today -- we have to nurture and realize that today's box dealer may be tomorrow's vintage specialist

**** And I love to point out this story, in my last year at Beckett we had a minor issue with the Almanac in which the 1993 Topps set checklist was missing about 200 cards due to a production error. You know, I swear we had several hundred complaints about that during the year --- and the Almanac was just as much for advanced collectors as basic collectors but if I forgot to put in a Pinkerton checklist, I'd bet I'd get 1-2 complaints during the year.

***** We have to remember, that we are an influential group, but a very small part of the hobby in many many ways

Happy holidays to all

Rich Klein

Regards and happy holidays

Rich

[bbcard1]

Also when there is a crappy local mall show, it gives you something to look at.

[mark evans]

I agree with those who opine that game-used items are not likely to increase in value over time, with the possible exception of scarce vintage items (Cobb signature, Jackson bat). It seems to me that the more GU cards of Jeter and LeBron are produced, the less the value of each one. To cite a 'recent' example, I would be stunned if the high-value LeBron 1/1 rookie that received such public attention would bring anywhere near its original value 10 years down the road.

[hunterdutchess]

I wonder what is next? They are gonna run out of these vintage items some day. I think (and this makes me sick) that they are actually going to take a authentic t206 Wagner or some other rare card and cut it up into little squares and them place them into new product. Just wait and see.

[cdn_collector]

Originally Posted by hunterdutchess

I think (and this makes me sick) that they are actually going to take a authentic t206 Wagner or some other rare card and cut it up into little squares and them place them into new product. Just wait and see.

Imagine that, eh? A series of modern cards that contain T206s. You could own a 'complete' T206 set without even owning a 'complete' T206. Of course, distinguishing between a 'Magie' and a 'Magee' could be tough

I guess when it's all said and done, it's really just a numbers game, though, right? How much does artifact X cost and how much market buzz and product sales can artifact X generate.

Regards,

Richard.