Net54Baseball Posting Pet Peeve - "Quoting" Scans

[canjond]

I actually have the opposite view. I prefer when someone quotes the scan so I don't have to go back through (sometimes) 4 pages of previous posts to figure out what card or item the quote referred to. When the 100th post in a string says "Killer card, Matt" and the scan isn't quoted, I then have to figure out who Matt is and what card was "killer."

[T206Collector]

Originally Posted by canjond

I actually have the opposite view. I prefer when someone quotes the scan so I don't have to go back through (sometimes) 4 pages of previous posts to figure out what card or item the quote referred to.

I am sure there are times when revisiting the scan makes some practical sense, but most of the time it's like:

1. Here's my gorgeous Cobb card + image
2. "Here's my gorgeous Cobb card + image" Hey nice Cobb card
3. "Here's my gorgeous Cobb card + image" Wow! Great Cobb card
4. ""Here's my gorgeous Cobb card + image" That Cobb is unbelievable.

There you have 4 scans of the same card and basically no useful added information other than the appropriate kudos for a gorgeous Cobb card.

[FrankWakefield]

.

[Leon]

Personally, I like using the quoting feature. It makes it easier to follow a conversation, for me, anyway. As for quoting scans, I can understand that being an annoyance. regards

[barrysloate]

I agree that there is far too much quoting on the board. It's a useful tool for an occasional reference, but it is used on almost every post and is often unnecessary.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

I agree that there is far too much quoting on the board. It's a useful tool for an occasional reference, but it is used on almost every post and is often unnecessary.

Almost every one? Well, maybe for some of us .

[Jim VB]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

I agree that there is far too much quoting on the board.

I wholeheartedly agree with Barry!

[barrysloate]

How did I know with absolute certainty that what I said was going to end up five minutes later as part of quote. You guys are predictable!

And I don't even know how to grab a quote.

[Jim VB]

Jon,

You mentioned "4 pages of previous posts". Are you aware that you can "fix" that?

Click "User CP" in the tool bar.

Click "Edit Options."

Scroll down to "Thread Display Options"

You can then adjust the "Number of Posts to Show Per Page."


It adjusts up to 80. Mosts threads never get longer than that. It may take a few seconds longer to load a page, but it greatly reduces threads with multiple pages.

[Jim VB]

Barry,

On the right side, bottom of every post is a "Quote" button.

Click on that and the entire post is in your reply.


You can also edit out certain parts and/or images as long as you leave in the brackets and the words Quote.

[calvindog]

[T206Collector]

Originally Posted by calvindog

That card is awesome!

[Jacklitsch]

Originally Posted by T206Collector

That card is awesome!

Yes, very very nice!

[FrankWakefield]

.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by FrankWakefield

Well I already had my posts per page set high....

Read the thread, then we don't need the 'quotes', they gobble up space, twice as much through which to scroll and at which to scowl. (Sorry, that last part was for Barry, our resident logophile. [And Leon, why isn't logophile in this site's dictionary?]).

We have a dictionary? (does this answer your question?)

Again, I think it's going to be a matter or personal preference if you like the quoting or not. I certainly understand about the scans being quoted, but for me who uses a standard desktop about 95% of the time, and don't even own an Iphone or Blackberry etc.....it works just fine.

[calvindog]

Originally Posted by Jacklitsch

Yes, very very nice!

That Cobb is superawesome!

[barrysloate]

Ted made a good point. Sometimes a very long post is quoted in its entirety, when only a sentence or two is relevant to what the next poster wants to say. Maybe shortening some of them would make for a good compromise. If I take the time to read somebody's long post, why should I be asked to read it again?

[canjond]

Originally Posted by calvindog

That Cobb is superawesome!

See, now I have to go back up and figure out which Cobb is superawesome since you didn't quote the photo.

[Jason Carota]

Originally Posted by canjond

When the 100th post in a string says "Killer card, Matt" and the scan isn't quoted, I then have to figure out who Matt is and what card was "killer."

I like the quote feature for extracting certain parts of posts. As for quoting scans, I use the following method (using Jeff's Cobb as an example):

----

Originally Posted by calvindog

Image of Ty Cobb HM Taylor Postcard

Beautiful card!

----