Did I Screw Up????

[rand1com]

You can bet William Chappell knew that was not Kid Nichols.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by rand1com

You can bet William Chappell knew that was not Kid Nichols.

I don't think the OP suggested William misled him.

[rand1com]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

I don't think the OP suggested William misled him.

Agreed.

Not suggesting that.

My point was William would not have had the card mis-priced badly on the low side due to not knowing who the card actually pictured.

William is an outstanding and fair dealer but very knowledgeable and meticulous.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by rand1com

Agreed.

Not suggesting that.

My point was William would not have had the card mis-priced badly on the low side due to not knowing who the card actually pictured.

William is an outstanding and fair dealer but very knowledgeable and meticulous.

Right, that's why I said before the price should have clued the OP in. Agree on William.

[Fred]

I'm pretty sure the Kid Nichols card is going to be substantially more than Hugh. Still not a bad card. Now you have a card of a player that holds the record for most SBs in a season!

[Gorditadogg]

Originally Posted by Fred

I'm pretty sure the Kid Nichols card is going to be substantially more than Hugh. Still not a bad card. Now you have a card of a player that holds the record for most SBs in a season!

I learned something on this thread. So Hugh Nicol = Nick Nicholl?

Sent from my SM-S906U using Tapatalk

[Johnny T]

I paid $800 for the card...I assume that is a reasonable price for the card. N172's don't seem to go cheap, even for commons.

I will probably post the card on our b/s/t section soon.

[rand1com]

An SGC 3 sold for $630 a year ago in an REA auction so I think the price for a 4 was very fair.

There has not been a recorded sale of an SGC 4 in VCP since 2011 and although it sold much lower in an auction in the $200 range, in 2008 there were 2 sales in the $500 ball park so again the price was probably very fair especially based on that 3 that sold last year and the trend 16 years ago for a 4.

Kid Nichols, depending on the pose, obviously sells for many times what you paid for this card.

[JollyElm]

How much over legitimate comp pricing did you pay?

That's sort of the real essence of the problem here. If you paid Kid Nichols' money for it, then that sucks. If you paid relatively close to Nick Nicholl's money for it, then at least the problem is minor, as you will be able to sell it and recoup the cost, or close to it