Another PSA mess up? major card - AA to 5

[MikeGarcia]

QUOTE :
Reminds me of the vintage Topps card I bought raw from Greg Morris last year as an "EXMT" card for about $50. It looked pretty good when it arrived though, so I sent it to PSA expecting a 7 but it came back in a 9 holder (pop 12 with none higher). Lol. I had no interest in owning a 9 though, so I bought another copy in similar condition for another $50 and sent the PSA 9 back to Greg Morris where some clown paid almost $5k for it because they just had to pip up the ranks on their registry. But like every other card in their collection, they just paid $5k for an over graded $50 card that was graded by an incompetent noobie grader at PSA.[/QUOTE]



Here at the I R S we call that post " evidence ". Please post more like this.

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by MikeGarcia

Here at the I R S we call that post " evidence ". Please post more like this.

OK, Mr Tax Man. Here's one for you from last week then.

Unlike you though, I actually pay my taxes.

[Carter08]

Originally Posted by Snowman

OK, Mr Tax Man. Here's one for you from last week then.

Unlike you though, I actually pay my taxes.

Congrats

[SyrNy1960]

Originally Posted by Snowman

OK, Mr Tax Man. Here's one for you from last week then.

Unlike you though, I actually pay my taxes.

Nice finish 🤑🤑🤑

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by Carter08

Congrats

Originally Posted by SyrNy1960

Nice finish 🤑🤑🤑

Thanks!

[etsmith]

I think it's funny how many people attack PSA, but everybody who sells cards ungraded has their own idea of what their cards grade. Buy two ungraded cards from two different dealers graded exactly the same by that seller and you'll get two cards that are actually completely different grades. PSA offers an opinion just like everybody who sells an upgraded card offers an opinion, it's up to the buyer to study the card before buying it to see if it matches the condition stated.

[jayshum]

Originally Posted by etsmith

I think it's funny how many people attack PSA, but everybody who sells cards ungraded has their own idea of what their cards grade. Buy two ungraded cards from two different dealers graded exactly the same by that seller and you'll get two cards that are actually completely different grades. PSA offers an opinion just like everybody who sells an upgraded card offers an opinion, it's up to the buyer to study the card before buying it to see if it matches the condition stated.

I guess the difference is that PSA is charging for their opinion so people expect them to meet a higher standard for the service they are providing, but you're right, people should look at the card not just the grade and decide for themselves if they agree with it or not.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by jayshum

I guess the difference is that PSA is charging for their opinion so people expect them to meet a higher standard for the service they are providing, but you're right, people should look at the card not just the grade and decide for themselves if they agree with it or not.

That's SO 2000s.

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by MikeGarcia

QUOTE :
Reminds me of the vintage Topps card I bought raw from Greg Morris last year as an "EXMT" card for about $50. It looked pretty good when it arrived though, so I sent it to PSA expecting a 7 but it came back in a 9 holder (pop 12 with none higher). Lol. I had no interest in owning a 9 though, so I bought another copy in similar condition for another $50 and sent the PSA 9 back to Greg Morris where some clown paid almost $5k for it because they just had to pip up the ranks on their registry. But like every other card in their collection, they just paid $5k for an over graded $50 card that was graded by an incompetent noobie grader at PSA.

Here at the I R S we call that post " evidence ". Please post more like this.[/QUOTE]

No baths in "distilled water" I gather