T206 Drum Johnson and others

[Bucket]

What do you think the other Drum backs would go for?

Originally Posted by brunswickreeves

Last (and only 1) HA in PSA 4 sold pre-Pandemic run up in 2019 for $75K. Discounting this new find by 50% for lower grade expectation, but then multiplying that by 3x to account for post-Pandemic run up, it could fetch over $100K.

[brunswickreeves]

Pelty went for $3.9K via HA in Jun ‘21 and Sweeney went for $2.2K. These would probably grade similar, so guess would be $8K and $4K respectively, however 2 bidders could drive them up higher.

[Bucket]

Thanks for the info. So there are actually 6 in total. There's a Dolin batting that isn't pictured.

Originally Posted by brunswickreeves

Pelty went for $3.9K via HA in Jun ‘21 and Sweeney went for $2.2K. These would probably grade similar, so guess would be $8K and $4K respectively, however 2 bidders could drive them up higher.

[MVSNYC]

I don't see any of those common Drums shown in the first post going for any less than $6-7k each...pretty clean and presentable examples...possibly would go higher.

[Bucket]

Would you all think the two main auction houses are REA and Goldin? Curious, what do this auction houses charge?

Originally Posted by MVSNYC

I don't see any of those common Drums shown in the first post going for any less than $6-7k each...pretty clean and presentable examples...possibly would go higher.

[JohnP0621]

Originally Posted by Bucket

Would you all think the two main auction houses are REA and Goldin? Curious, what do this auction houses charge?

I think that once you get them graded you could get the auction houses to forgo any sellers fees. These are that rare and the AH will still do very well with only the buyers premiums.

Good Luck
Fabulous cards .

Regards
John P

[brunswickreeves]

IMHO-There should be absolutely zero sellers fee on these. In fact, you should negotiate for 3-5% of the 20% buyers premium, which an AH will happily comply with for the prestige to sell these. If not, next next. Further, I would negotiate for a reserve of $50K on the Matty since it’s ultra rare and you don’t want to take a bath on it if buyers are asleep. Lastly find an AH that’s willing to bring to and promote at the National for additional exposure and promo of a concurrent auction in which it is offered (e.g. Summer Platinum Night with HA).

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Bucket

Would you all think the two main auction houses are REA and Goldin? Curious, what do this auction houses charge?

I would think these cards would get lost in Goldins modern cesspool, choose an AH that knows how to treat these cards. LOTG, REA, Heritage, Sterling, Mile High, etc.