PSA Appraisal Values

[Oscar_Stanage]

Originally Posted by Snowman

It'd be one thing if they were off by a half point, or if the card was pretty borderline and it's off by a full grade. But there should never be a situation where a card is off by 2 full grades, let alone 3 or more. But this is precisely what's happening right now at PSA.

I'm talking about VG+ cards in PSA 1 holders. It's getting absurd. They need to get their $#!+ together.

Can you share some examples? I do not think I have seen such egregious mis-grades.

[incugator]

Glyn,

There are public sales, private sales, raw card sales,, sales of the card in a different slab. If a card sells raw on a public sale for $450 but then get graded for $30, and the most recent public sale of the card in that grade is $600, PSA is says it’s worth $600. Discussion over.

-Ryan

[Snowman]

Originally Posted by Oscar_Stanage

Can you share some examples? I do not think I have seen such egregious mis-grades.

I could, but I'd prefer not to because I cracked them all out of their holders and had them regraded. I don't need the BODA crew finding a speck of lint on the PSA 1 scan that is absent on the SGC 3.5 scan and publicly accusing me of "recoloring" for profit (on a card that isn't even for sale, lol). It's a small sample size, but this has happened to me on 5 different cards across 3 separate orders in recent months.