FS: 1888 Yum Yum Tobacco N403 Billy Sunday

[alywa]

Wow. What a gorgeous card

[oldjudge]

Tanner--thanks for pointing out that it is a mislabeled card of Baldwin. Contrary to what the grading companies may say, the convention in these cases is that the photo determines the player, not the name at the bottom (see Old Judge book) of the card. This should be listed as a Baldwin card.

[mouschi]

Originally Posted by alywa

Wow. What a gorgeous card

Thank you!

Just as a heads up to anyone watching, the price is negotiable - wasn't really sure what to put it at. (Though if anyone has a massive critique, please PM me it, instead of telling me it is worth $2 here LOL!)

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Tanner--thanks for pointing out that it is a mislabeled card of Baldwin. Contrary to what the grading companies may say, the convention in these cases is that the photo determines the player, not the name at the bottom (see Old Judge book) of the card. This should be listed as a Baldwin card.

Hey Jay! Thanks for chiming in. I guess it's 6 one way, half a dozen another - the other mistaken identity cards like the 87 Donruss Opening Day / 90 Donruss John Smoltz for example, I've always gone by the name (Bonds/Smoltz) instead of pic Ray/Glavine, but I wouldn't disagree one bit if someone said it the other way around.

It does remind me a couple of years ago, Topps called Shane Beiber "Justin Beiber" on the back of the card. A 10 cent card (uncorrected, mind you) went for CRAZY money. We cardboard crack addicts are crazy sometimes!

[oldjudge]

Originally Posted by mouschi

Thank you!

Just as a heads up to anyone watching, the price is negotiable - wasn't really sure what to put it at. (Though if anyone has a massive critique, please PM me it, instead of telling me it is worth $2 here LOL!)



Hey Jay! Thanks for chiming in. I guess it's 6 one way, half a dozen another - the other mistaken identity cards like the 87 Donruss Opening Day / 90 Donruss John Smoltz for example, I've always gone by the name (Bonds/Smoltz) instead of pic Ray/Glavine, but I wouldn't disagree one bit if someone said it the other way around.

It does remind me a couple of years ago, Topps called Shane Beiber "Justin Beiber" on the back of the card. A 10 cent card (uncorrected, mind you) went for CRAZY money. We cardboard crack addicts are crazy sometimes!

The British Cartophilic Society, who really did most of the initial cataloging of 19th century cards, adopted this convention. It could have gone either way but I think when you look at how the card was made(first the image went on, then the name plate below) at least for Old Judges it made perfect sense for the image to govern. This is why we decided to continue with it in the Old Judge book. For most cards it doesn’t matter value wise, but the Anson who isn’t Anson should be a different story.

[mouschi]

Price drop!

[mrreality68]

wow nice looking card and sharp eye appeal

[mouschi]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

wow nice looking card and sharp eye appeal

Thank you good sir!