Who are your Inner Circle Hall of Famers?

[Fred]

How "tight" is the "inner-circle" supposed to be? I look at any player that has reached the basic milestones (500HRs, 3000H, 300W) are inner-circle. I'm sure other milestone criteria could be used. I suppose PED users are considered if you don't mind adding them.

Then there are those that haven't hit any of the milestones like Gehrig or DiMaggio that some might consider for their inner-circle.

Bottom line, it would be fun to put together a survey of this board to see who their top 50 or even 100 players are. Provide a rank number and the end result would be the highest ranking players. My guess is that a lot of the players selected by the old veterans committee wouldn't make the cut.

[MuncieNolePAZ]

Originally Posted by Fred

Bottom line, it would be fun to put together a survey of this board to see who their top 50 or even 100 players are. Provide a rank number and the end result would be the highest ranking players.

This could be fun. Not sure of order, but off the top of my head, my top ten would be Cobb, Ruth, Mays, WaJo, Aaron, Bonds, Wagner, Ted Williams, Clemens, Gehrig.

Chad