T206 Ty Cobb Hindu Red...

[RCFire82]

Did anyone else see this one get swooped up on Ebay the other day? Even with the condition, feel like $1500 was a steal. Any thoughts?

[atx840]

It looked real to me, word is it will be either re-listed or sent to a larger AH. Seller did not go through with the sale.

[RCFire82]

Good to know Chris. Feel better knowing I didn't miss out on that opportunity.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Not that I have any dog in the fight, but this card got a lot of attention immediately after the sale. I wish people would hold off on discussions like that until the sale had a chance to be completed. The buyer pretty much got screwed out of a huge opportunity.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Not that I have any dog in the fight, but this card got a lot of attention immediately after the sale. I wish people would hold off on discussions like that until the sale had a chance to be completed. The buyer pretty much got screwed out of a huge opportunity.

yup...its the current reality! renegging on deals after one realizes money was left on the table.

[T205 GB]

Some years back wasn't there a Red Portrait Cobb w/Red Hindu back that came up and then was proven fake? Anyone happen to do a comparison of these two cards to see if it was altered to look this way now. Isn't there an unwritten rule with Prewar that if its to good to be true it probably is. I believe that fake Cobb was at the 2012 National and was rebacked. I could just be imagining things too

[x2drich2000]

Andrew, not sure about the red Cobb/red hindu, but here are two threads I found quickly that reference a red cobb with a rebacked drum and a green cobb with red hindu. The second also references a red cobb with red Hindu that was questioned.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=87462

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=140161

[Rhotchkiss]

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

there are plenty of people who'd pay 5 figures for this card...just not u! Or I for that matter! T206 collectors are fanatical!

[KMayUSA6060]

The original theory I heard was another 0 was intended to be in the price. Albeit sloppy, that would have been more understandable.

Cancelling the sale because you realized you could get ~8-10x the price - not a good look.

[MVSNYC]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

This.

I'm with Ryan. We both are (like many T206 collectors) rare back fanatics...However, no matter how rare the card is, if you can't see the brand name, or hardly much of the back, then what's the point?...It's also rather risky buying a high-profile card raw.

(I posted in that old "Archive" thread from 2007 )

[Leon]

Originally Posted by KMayUSA6060

The original theory I heard was another 0 was intended to be in the price. Albeit sloppy, that would have been more understandable.

Cancelling the sale because you realized you could get ~8-10x the price - not a good look.

I don't think he gets a ton more. The value is in the back and it sucks bad.
.

[T205 GB]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

Andrew, not sure about the red Cobb/red hindu, but here are two threads I found quickly that reference a red cobb with a rebacked drum and a green cobb with red hindu. The second also references a red cobb with red Hindu that was questioned.

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=87462

https://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=140161

Yes that second thread says it all. Stared with a Green Cobb but discussed that Fake Red one most the thread.

[jjp3rd]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Not that I have any dog in the fight, but this card got a lot of attention immediately after the sale. I wish people would hold off on discussions like that until the sale had a chance to be completed. The buyer pretty much got screwed out of a huge opportunity.

Scott—You are 100% correct on this. I totally agree.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[edhans]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

+1.

[KMayUSA6060]

Originally Posted by Leon

I don't think he gets a ton more. The value is in the back and it sucks bad.
.

What does a whole-back Red Hindu Red Cobb Portrait go for in a 1/poor A condition?

[Sean]

Originally Posted by KMayUSA6060

What does a whole-back Red Hindu Red Cobb Portrait go for in a 1/poor A condition?

My guess is $50K+ if the card is complete but in poor condition.

[YankeeHotelFoxtrot]

For a card not graded, no one knows for sure if it is real. Guess all you want, no one knows.

So, what money was left on the table? Potentially someone gets ripped off?

The risk is not the seller's, but the buyer's

[slightlyrounded]

I would ask PSA to slab this as a “Hindu no Hindu” variation personally.

[chriskim]

GENIUNE serial #00000003

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

Another vote for this! If even genuine, far too much of the back is gone and that's the money shot.

[Republicaninmass]

Hin...dont

[KMayUSA6060]

Originally Posted by Sean

My guess is $50K+ if the card is complete but in poor condition.

Based on this, $1500 is an absolute steal for someone who wants a Red Hindu Cobb (assuming it's authentic).

[Yoda]

Remember the excitement when a BL 460 of Cobb was discovered a few years ago.

[jjp3rd]

Originally Posted by KMayUSA6060

Based on this, $1500 is an absolute steal for someone who wants a Red Hindu Cobb (assuming it's authentic).

Completely agree


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[chriskim]

OMG... I found a sister card for this Cobb. What a perfect match! LOL


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Y-WcB9Nm3U&t=2s

[Luke]

Cards like this make me feel a little sad knowing what they once were. Often I feel like it's more sad than cool to own them. But I would definitely want this one.

[Aaron Seefeldt]

Holy Cow! I just read the old thread regarding the Red Hindu Cobb in a PSA 4 holder...

I was the one who consigned it to REA. I went through a nasty divorce in 2008 and I had to sell off all my collection in 2007 & 2008 as most of my liquidity was tied into the cards, photos, and postcards. You may recall the e125 set in REA in 2007 as well as several Boston Garters (locker room series) and a complete m110 set, Victory Cobb, etc... man o' man, divorce sucks!

I got out of the hobby after the divorce but kept 1 card, the Red Hindu Cobb. I ended up selling it in REA a year or 2 later to help a friend who's business needed money.

But I was not back into the hobby until 2016 or so. I would purchase a card here or there through auction but didn't consider myself "reactivated" until about 2016.

I did not look at Net54 for several years after the divorce and had NO idea the Red Hindu caused that much controversy until just now, reading the above post. I bought it at a Chicago Sun-Times show from a dealer who was from California, I do not recall his name. A year or so after I sold it Lifson did tell me that there were many questions regarding the cards authenticity, etc.

Was the card real? I have no idea. I never owned the card before it was graded, didn't have a chance to properly evaluate it myself (the ol' smell test never failed). It was in a slab BUT I had bought a PSA graded Cobb bat on & a PSA Cobb green (both with regular Hindu backs, not red) a few years earlier... they both turned out to be fake, re-backed. Fortunately, I got my money back as I paid $10K for the 2 which was a ton of money back then.

Leon, thank you for not revealing me as the consignor. Yes, I did back out of the deal for the Red Hindu Cobb with you but I do recall you still got my d304 Martens Cobb? I give you 100% respect for keeping me anonymous. Many many thanks.

Unfortunately I cannot afford 90% of the cards I sold back then, they've just taken off out of reach.

[Sean]

A Victory Cobb!!!

[Sean]

Originally Posted by Yoda

Remember the excitement when a BL 460 of Cobb was discovered a few years ago.

I recall that I doubted its authenticity. Boy, was I proven wrong.

[Popcorn]

the card looks good imo, I’ve seen regular beat up cobbs go for 2-3k with no back so 1,500 was probably a pretty good deal.

[Aaron Seefeldt]

Originally Posted by Sean

A Victory Cobb!!!

It was the one that was recently in Heritage...

[BobbyStrawberry]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

Assuming the card is authentic, I would not pay $1500 for the card, let alone more. The "value" is in the red hindu back and you can barely see anything, including no "Hindu". Personally, I would much rather have a complete and decent looking common-back red cobb for the same price it will cost to acquire this monster.

Agreed. I've been after a lower grade Cobb T206 for awhile now, and I wouldn't touch this for even $1k. To each their own though!

[chriskim]

Originally Posted by Popcorn

the card looks good imo, I’ve seen regular beat up cobbs go for 2-3k with no back so 1,500 was probably a pretty good deal.

What about a beat up Cobb front? 2-3k as well??

[chriskim]

Originally Posted by Aaron Seefeldt

Holy Cow! I just read the old thread regarding the Red Hindu Cobb in a PSA 4 holder...

I was the one who consigned it to REA. I went through a nasty divorce in 2008 and I had to sell off all my collection in 2007 & 2008 as most of my liquidity was tied into the cards, photos, and postcards. You may recall the e125 set in REA in 2007 as well as several Boston Garters (locker room series) and a complete m110 set, Victory Cobb, etc... man o' man, divorce sucks!

I got out of the hobby after the divorce but kept 1 card, the Red Hindu Cobb. I ended up selling it in REA a year or 2 later to help a friend who's business needed money.

But I was not back into the hobby until 2016 or so. I would purchase a card here or there through auction but didn't consider myself "reactivated" until about 2016.

I did not look at Net54 for several years after the divorce and had NO idea the Red Hindu caused that much controversy until just now, reading the above post. I bought it at a Chicago Sun-Times show from a dealer who was from California, I do not recall his name. A year or so after I sold it Lifson did tell me that there were many questions regarding the cards authenticity, etc.

Was the card real? I have no idea. I never owned the card before it was graded, didn't have a chance to properly evaluate it myself (the ol' smell test never failed). It was in a slab BUT I had bought a PSA graded Cobb bat on & a PSA Cobb green (both with regular Hindu backs, not red) a few years earlier... they both turned out to be fake, re-backed. Fortunately, I got my money back as I paid $10K for the 2 which was a ton of money back then.

Leon, thank you for not revealing me as the consignor. Yes, I did back out of the deal for the Red Hindu Cobb with you but I do recall you still got my d304 Martens Cobb? I give you 100% respect for keeping me anonymous. Many many thanks.

Unfortunately I cannot afford 90% of the cards I sold back then, they've just taken off out of reach.

Thx for sharing your story. OMG, you really have bad luck buying fake PSA graded Cobbs? not just one, but two?? I am happy you got your money back.

[Popcorn]

Originally Posted by chriskim

What about a beat up Cobb front? 2-3k as well??

you would definitely get bids

1,850 for this… https://www.ebay.com/itm/165128442689

[Sean]

Originally Posted by Aaron Seefeldt

It was the one that was recently in Heritage...

The one that didn't meet the reserve?

[Aaron Seefeldt]

It was the SGC2 Cobb Victory that was in the auction with “ALL” the other red portrait Cobbs.

[chriskim]

Originally Posted by Aaron Seefeldt

It was the SGC2 Cobb Victory that was in the auction with “ALL” the other red portrait Cobbs.

It is very interesting that Cobb Victory is not searchable in HA database, may be because reserve not met?

[T205 GB]

Originally Posted by chriskim

It is very interesting that Cobb Victory is not searchable in HA database, may be because reserve not met?

My dad and I can not find a lot of the auctions that we buy on HA either. We know we got them from HA, have the invoice with all the info and what we paid but finding the wrong card or nothing at all is far to common with them.

[Blunder19]

ill add some Cobb RH motivation to this thread..

[pawpawdiv9]

its there, you got to search tab (all sold & unsold items)
https://sports.ha.com/c/search-resul...rch-A-Y-071316
ITEM HERE LINK: (Victory Ty Cobb RED)
https://sports.ha.com/itm/baseball/1...ription-071515

[atx840]

Amazing Jamie!

[Sean]

Originally Posted by chriskim

It is very interesting that Cobb Victory is not searchable in HA database, may be because reserve not met?

You are correct, however, the reserve was not met.

[Carter08]

Woah on those cards.

[T205 GB]

Originally Posted by Blunder19

ill add some Cobb RH motivation to this thread..

Do you have this card because its a Frankenstein? Would love to hear more about it. Didn't Wonka (John McDaniels?) have some controversy when these Red Hindus showed up? Circa 2009-2010.

BTW, Jamie hope your doing good. Been a while.

[Blunder19]

Andrew,

I have this card because its the real mccoy... One of only a handful known Red Cobbs with a Red Hindu back..

i also own that Victory Cobb which is shown in the messages above..

[atx840]

Originally Posted by T205 GB

Do you have this card because its a Frankenstein? Would love to hear more about it. Didn't Wonka (John McDaniels?) have some controversy when these Red Hindus showed up? Circa 2009-2010.

BTW, Jamie hope your doing good. Been a while.

Jamie's Cobb was part of a 42 RH find back in 2012 that were auctioned off by SCP. Wonka wanted one to complete a player back run, it was bid up to 32k.

https://catalog.scpauctions.com/1909...-LOT20959.aspx

A thread discussing the new Cobbs found
https://www.net54baseball.com/showth...u+SCP+auctions

[t206kid]

I have one of the Wajos from that find. The back is amazingly bright

[atx840]

Fantastic card Jay!

I won the Chase, which is still one of my favourites.