Winners of the First Auction

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by darwinbulldog

How were the prices compared to what similar looking cards listed as trimmed would bring on eBay?

really hard to tell...I just looked at VCP for prices of 52 topps robinsons. The one sold in cardiman for over 3K which is around psa 5 valuation. No authentics have sold anywhere near this price from what I see...then again this one "appears" nicer than any other A's I saw.

personally I think the cardiman one is trimmed...so according to vcp price is in the stratosphere...if it turns out to be altered.

[cardsnstuff]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

really hard to tell...I just looked at VCP for prices of 52 topps robinsons. The one sold in cardiman for over 3K which is around psa 5 valuation. No authentics have sold anywhere near this price from what I see...then again this one "appears" nicer than any other A's I saw.

personally I think the cardiman one is trimmed...so according to vcp price is in the stratosphere...if it turns out to be altered.

Wow, that is amazing.

[ezez420]

Card does not look trimmed and has rough cut.

[frankbmd]

Originally Posted by ezez420

Card does not look trimmed and has rough cut.

“Rough” trim.

[irv]

I hate to sound like a pessimist, but my guy tells me we will never here from Candiman auctions ever again.

Some of the cards that didn't sell may pop somewhere else, but, imo, they will be blended in with other cards from another seller disguising them.

[ezez420]

Your Guy. What you can’t think for yourself and need someone to tell you what “he” thinks? What kind of crap is that? I think people are stupid if the DID NOT bid. With the trail of the post and the guarantees by the seller AND the fact that this can be paid with credit card you are a moron if you think otherwise.

Originally Posted by irv

I hate to sound like a pessimist, but my guy tells me we will never here from Candiman auctions ever again.

Some of the cards that didn't sell may pop somewhere else, but, imo, they will be blended in with other cards from another seller disguising them.

[pokerplyr80]

Originally Posted by ezez420

Your Guy. What you can’t think for yourself and need someone to tell you what “he” thinks? What kind of crap is that? I think people are stupid if the DID NOT bid. With the trail of the post and the guarantees by the seller AND the fact that this can be paid with credit card you are a moron if you think otherwise.

Pretty sure he meant "my gut." I'd have to say I agree with Irv's assessment. Best of luck to those who took a gamble. But the smart money was on sitting out of this one.

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by ezez420

I think people are stupid if the DID NOT bid.

What if I didn't bid because I didn't want to put any of my money into the pockets of grifters like the Battles family?