Modern Era HOF Ballot: Who do you think should get in?

[dgo71]

Murphy definitely gets my vote. Tiant and Trammell are deserving too imo.

[packs]

Don Mattingly

[CW]

Weird... I thought Dale Murphy was already in.

[cardsfan44]

Ted Simmons to me is an issue one that got the shaft many years ago. He was essentially punished for not being in the same category as Johnny Bench. His numbers for a catcher should make him a lock

[bn2cardz]

Lou Whitaker... oh wait a second...

I like a few guys on the list, but in my opinion Marvin Miller is the most important and should've been in a long time ago.

[pclpads]

Originally Posted by NewEnglandBaseBallist

I like a few guys on the list, but in my opinion Marvin Miller is the most important and should've been in a long time ago.

+1 The others make the list of the "very good," but not HOF worthy.

[the 'stache]

I watched Simba play at Milwaukee County Stadium. When you consider the dimensions of the field, and its proximity to Lake Michigan, that the Brewers hit as many home runs as they did in the early 80s is a miracle. Of all those guys, Ted Simmons, I swear, hit the ball the hardest. It just made a different sound.

He should have been in years ago.

Originally Posted by cardsfan44

Ted Simmons to me is an issue one that got the shaft many years ago. He was essentially punished for not being in the same category as Johnny Bench. His numbers for a catcher should make him a lock