Which would you rather have?

[BBB]

I'm on the fence. The Cobb is harder to find. But the Aaron rookie is more significant. There are 3 other Cobbs in T206. Only 1 Aaron rookie from topps.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[7nohitter]

Cobb....great eye appeal and probably a decent price based on the grade......'buy the card not the holder!'

[irv]

Because I currently collect cards from mostly the 50's and 60's, I'd likely choose the Aaron, but for me, as I'd also love to own a Cobb, it would likely come down to which one I could afford more. (Which I am sure this isn't a problem here?)

2 very nice cards that I'd love to own.

[jb67]

I would go with the Cobb. Great eye-appeal for the grade. You can find PSA 3 Aaron rookies with better appeal than the PSA 4 you have listed. It would be much harder to find Cobb with better eye-appeal with a lower grade. My 2 cents.

[DBesse27]

Cobb, hands down.