How does a card w/ paper loss grade a 4?

[tbob]

I've seen similar cards on ebay in SGC 10 holders

[ValKehl]

I would grade this T206 Young card a 1.5.
Val

[cammb]

Originally Posted by tbob

I've seen similar cards on ebay in SGC 10 holders

Exactly! Thats why PSA sucks.

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by cammb

Exactly! Thats why PSA sucks.

How does SGC give grades of SGC 60 and they are completely miscut at the bottom? Willis on Ebay, and Joss?? No complaints on these....

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by cammb

Exactly! Thats why PSA sucks.

Except when you want resale value, right Tony?

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by tbob

I've seen similar cards on ebay in SGC 10 holders

I have also seen T206's graded SGC 60 and higher with rounded corners....beating a dead horse again....

[Peter_Spaeth]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

I have also seen T206's graded SGC 60 and higher with rounded corners....beating a dead horse again....

Not sure those are mistakes though, Kevin.

[T205 GB]

I have a PSA 4 T205 Schulte with pin holes you can see daylight through in all corners. IMO PSA is know for their lax grading standards. As long as the money keeps rolling in though it will continue.

[glynparson]

Equals many more mistakes.

[robw1959]

Agreed! But when you grow in size as a company, your staff should grow accordingly in order to accommodate that growth in business. Especially with regard to fine vintage issues they ought to have some experts who are consistent in adhering to their published grading standards. Personally I believe SGC is far more accurate on a more consistent basis.

[z28jd]

I have a PSA 5 Old Judge card with two dots of paper loss on the front, one about the size of a pin head, one a little smaller. Got the card from a friend who just got it graded, so I know it was legit. The funny thing is I also bought a PSA 2 at the same time and it was much nicer than the 5