The Hall of Fame postcard plaque thread

[Smanzari]

Originally Posted by brooklynbaseball

I told her the Campanella was definitely bad, also had some doubts on the Medwick. These all look good to me, you don't agree?

I would have proceeded with caution with those (I'm not an expert but 1-2 look "off"). Do you have a pic of the Campy? All of his look pretty rough....

[brooklynbaseball]

I did proceed "with caution" as I always do with ebay sellers. The only one of these that I had a bit of trepidation about was the Frisch, but upon close inspection, it seemed to match up well with the others in my possession. The Campy is still on ebay, it is ghost signed, looks like whomever signed it was trying to duplicate his pre-accident signature. The only "signatures" possible by him on these cards were signed by him using his apparatus.

[Smanzari]

Yea, that was one that also stood out to me (and the Stengel front, which is probably Really late in his life!)!

I do like the inscriptions on the Carey and the back of the Stengel!

[brooklynbaseball]

Yep, Stengel is often hard to judge, but this one is golden. I have 2 photos signed the same way. He was always one of my favorites!

[Wrightfan85]

Nice additions. I feel like my Max Carey is the only one he didn't personalize

[dgo71]

Originally Posted by Wrightfan85

I feel like my Max Carey is the only one he didn't personalize

There are at least 2 out there because mine is not personalized either!

[doug.goodman]

Here is one of my favorites. He passed away before he made that August trip to Cooperstown.

Doug