What is the most controversial card now?

[wolterse]

Cobb-Edwards Wagner?

[terjung]

Originally Posted by wolterse

Cobb-Edwards Wagner?

Controversial? Hardly.

Notorious, perhaps.

[David W]

It's probably still the Gretzky/McNall Wagner with nothing at all close to it.

It's gone from PSA 8 to PSA Authentic, decreasing (in theory) it's value by 80%.

But with someone going to prison over the card, it may hold it's value.

Maybe. I bet whoever owns it hopes it does.

[wonkaticket]

All this talk of the card trimming and the card keeping its original untrimmed value is great news. Now if I can just link my few trimmed cards to the hands of the Trim Master General Bill Mastro they are sure to jump in value to pre-trimmed prices!

Perhaps I can get SGC and PSA to do pedigree flips “Mastro Job”.

[e107collector]

Any thoughts on what PSA will now do with the PSA 8 Wagner? Is it up to the current owner to contact them, or do they have to reach out to him to correct their mistake?

Also, if they re-grade the Wagner "Authentic," how would they determine the current value, without auctioning it off?

And, if they compensate the current owner for their mistake, does he have to give it the card to PSA at that point?

Tony

[ullmandds]

I'm guessing they do nothing...and the current owner couldn't care less.

[Cardboard Junkie]

I think Kendricks should, (and probably does) have a bunch of three piece suits advising him on this conundrum.