Gentleman James (Jim) Corbett authenticity opinions

[ibuysportsephemera]

So when everything was said and done....what did Travis say about this autograph?

Jeff

[thetruthisoutthere]

Originally Posted by ibuysportsephemera

So when everything was said and done....what did Travis say about this autograph?

Jeff

Has it been six weeks yet...........

[thenavarro]

Originally Posted by ibuysportsephemera

So when everything was said and done....what did Travis say about this autograph?

Jeff

Jeff,

I did not hear a final decision from Travis, nor did I see one posted anywhere. However, we all know authentication cannot be rushed, so he is probably still studying and researching to make his determination. In all fairness, I did not pay for his opinion, so I shouldn't expect to receive it, nor do I subscribe to his particular mantra, so if he doesn't want to assist when the time comes, that's fine too. However, another very knowledgeable boxing collector, Mark Ogren, posted a couple of screen shots from his fantastic exemplar collection, which leads me to believe that Mr. Ogren thinks my Corbett was authentic. I make that assumption, perhaps erroneously, from the file names that you can see at the top of each exemplar. If you look at my photo on his screen, you will see the date and sr.jpg. I'm not 100% sure, but I believe that is the convention he uses for naming the authentic ones. If you look at his exemplar screen shots, you will see some termed Non authentic or something along those lines in the file name. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the file name on mine does not say that and is in the convention of the authentic exemplars. Who knows though. Perhaps Mark will chime in and say that's not what his file naming conventions mean, or that he mistakenly labeled mine authentic and it's not. I do know that after all my research into it, in my untrained boxing autograph eye, it appears to me to have enough similarities to other Corbett signatures of that time period that are purported to be authentic.

I believe it's 100% legit.

Here's the screenshots to peruse.

[ibuysportsephemera]

Originally Posted by thenavarro

Jeff,

I did not hear a final decision from Travis, nor did I see one posted anywhere. However, we all know authentication cannot be rushed, so he is probably still studying and researching to make his determination. In all fairness, I did not pay for his opinion, so I shouldn't expect to receive it, nor do I subscribe to his particular mantra, so if he doesn't want to assist when the time comes, that's fine too. However, another very knowledgeable boxing collector, Mark Ogren, posted a couple of screen shots from his fantastic exemplar collection, which leads me to believe that Mr. Ogren thinks my Corbett was authentic. I make that assumption, perhaps erroneously, from the file names that you can see at the top of each exemplar. If you look at my photo on his screen, you will see the date and sr.jpg. I'm not 100% sure, but I believe that is the convention he uses for naming the authentic ones. If you look at his exemplar screen shots, you will see some termed Non authentic or something along those lines in the file name. To the best of my knowledge and belief, the file name on mine does not say that and is in the convention of the authentic exemplars. Who knows though. Perhaps Mark will chime in and say that's not what his file naming conventions mean, or that he mistakenly labeled mine authentic and it's not. I do know that after all my research into it, in my untrained boxing autograph eye, it appears to me to have enough similarities to other Corbett signatures of that time period that are purported to be authentic.

I believe it's 100% legit.

Here's the screenshots to peruse.

I agree Mike...I think it looks good as well. I hated to hijack your thread...but with all the drama surrounding Travis, I wanted to see what constructive threads (if any) that Travis was involved in. This was the best I could find, and it didn't appear that he followed up with you.

All the best.

Jeff

[chaddurbin]

funny, so they hijacked your scan to put in their examplar files, but didn't have the courtesy to at least tell you it's authentic...or taking your photo.

[thenavarro]

Originally Posted by chaddurbin

funny, so they hijacked your scan to put in their examplar files, but didn't have the courtesy to at least tell you it's authentic...or taking your photo.

Mark added the following line when he posted the exemplar pic:

"Compliments of the boxing guys if it will help alleviate the silly Jim Corbett issue:"

then underneath that he posted the exemplar pic that contained my pic.

Perhaps not the most direct way to state something, and again, I might have inferred wrong, but I believe in context of his post, that meant he (Mark O.) thought it was real. Perhaps also, when he used the term "boxing guys", maybe he meant Travis as well, and perhaps he was speaking (by typing) for him too. I'm not sure and didn't care to inquire further at the time.

Mike

[Exhibitman]

Originally Posted by thenavarro

Mark added the following line when he posted the exemplar pic:

"Compliments of the boxing guys if it will help alleviate the silly Jim Corbett issue:"

Shouldn't that be the boxing "group"?