Any opinions on this card being genuine?

[tbob]

I see some red flags with the snow white borders and color looking "öff" but I wondered if anyone else had an opinion? The bidding has been sporadic and the card is at around $250, a lot for a reprint but a tiny fraction of what this card is worth if real. Seller says absolutely no returns but believes it is genuine. Lots of red flags, although 100% feedback on ebay. Listing number 200965244817. Sorry I can't make links on my laptop. E95 Matty in CSA 8.5 holder. Looks NM.

[philliesfan]

My first thought at first glance is reprint but I am no expert.

Red Flags = probable fake.

Robert

[calvindog]

Bob, that's about as fake as fake can be.

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by calvindog

Bob, that's about as fake as fake can be.

Very much agree with Jeff! Isn't that the same grading company as the Cobb/Edwards Wagner??

[Paul S]

Bleh!! Love the "Matthewson" (sic)

Slow Sunday for you?

[buymycards]

Wouldn't you think if you were making a fake card you would at least spell his freaking name correctly?

Sincerely,

Baib Rooth.

[Mark]

Compare

[conor912]

Originally Posted by tbob

Seller says absolutely no returns

One of the reddest of red flags.

[egbeachley]

Since EBay doesn't seem to care about buyers making bid retractions, has anyone considered making a large bid that is shilled up and them making there own bid retraction right before the 12-hour limit? That way the shiller gets stuck paying the EBay fees.