Authentic '55 Koufax?

[novakjr]

Originally Posted by HOF Auto Rookies

How do you figured this is a 1? This card, if authentic, is gorgeous and would easily grade a 6 at best. IMHO

I don't want to mention the price because the price would skew ppl's opinions on whether this is authentic or not. If it sold for a low amount, ppl would think it isn't authentic beacuse Sandy charges $400 to sign a card, and a card of this card is worth at least $400-$600+ alone. If it sold for a high amount, then ppl will believe that it is indeed authentic or why would someone pay that much for a questionable card...IMHO

Assuming the card IS authentic, if the signature is NOT authentic, then the card is probably a 1 because of the writing...Possibly, not even gradable, because of the fraudulent signature. They may not wanna slab it, because it could create some confusion as to whether or not the signature is authentic.. I think that's what Keith was trying to say..