Most undervalued HOFers

[G1911]

Originally Posted by packs

Why haven’t you guys said you would choose Perry over Ryan?

Because it's not my claim, my claim for the 10,000th time is that Perry and Ryan are different types of pitchers who produced pretty similar values. I know you guys would like easier things to argue against because this statement is, for mysterious reasons, quite upsetting to several people but none of you can think of an actual argument against it, but I am not interested in changing my claim.

My subsequent claim is that your claim that no one on Earth would select Perry over Ryan is demonstrably false, and that you trying to pretend James does not count because you don't like that is both really funny and completely disconnected from reality.