e98 matty

[Archive]

Posted By: Bruce Perry

since there are so few graded, why does the SMR (which most knowledgeable people will agree is worthless for pre WW 1)list the much more commom e92, e93 matty's higher in value for grade 3/4? what does an e98 matty in grade 4 retail for?...thanks

[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

Hi Bruce- I think this may be your first post, so welcome to the board.

You first have to throw out SMR as there are just too many inaccuracies. An E98 Matty in a 4 is a pretty expensive card; a PSA 3 sold in March on ebay for $2900+, so a price of $3500 for a 4 sounds reasonable and perhaps even conservative. You also can get a bit of a premium for a tougher color (I need help on that one).

And since you logged in as uclakid I'm guessing Daniel decided for sure to go to UCLA. I wish him well.

Barry

[Archive]

Posted By: Anonymous

there are none graded above 4 according to the psa pop info...and one of the psa 4's was a 4 twice.....sgc does not seem to have one in their pop information (or I just missed it)..........I wish there was someway to accurately price popular cards like (very few graded) these instead of just guessing when one does come up for sale

[Archive]

Posted By: JimB

SMR is virtually useless on caramels. However, the thinking may be that E93s are more popular in general than E98s. Hard to say for sure what they are thinking.
JimB

[Archive]

Posted By: Jeff Williams

[Archive]

Posted By: BcD

I piad Tim Sedlock ( thank you Tim ) $750 for a psa 4 Blue he had as buy it now in 2003.

someone purchaed a red psa 4 for $3600 on a buy it now in 2005

Quan had a gold SGC 70 he sold for $1850 I believe in 2003 or 4.

dont know if this helps but I suspect someone can get $4000 for ne as they are somewhat elusive to find~

BcD

[Archive]

Posted By: Brett

I'll trade ya this one I won on ebay recently crappy scanner left lines in the scan...

If anyone has a red or green e98 Matty in poor shape, i'd be interested !

[Archive]

Posted By: JimB

Got mine from Scott Brockelman. Thanks Scott.

[Archive]

Posted By: Bruce

you collectors (dealers?) are amazing....would like to meet you at a national sometime and talk about caramels....I will be setup in cleveland..maybe I will find a decent e98 matty there....for around 3 or 4 thousand.....thanks

[Archive]

Posted By: BD

not as nice as Jim's though!




BcD