Help me decide.

[Vintagedeputy]

I posted this previously on a different sub-forum but it may get more traction here. I know these aren’t all pre-war but I’d love to get some opinions.
I want to send in 10 of these cards to SGC for grading for my PC (except the Space card which will be sold). Which 10 would you choose? Assume the backs are as clean/same condition at the fronts.

Feel free to ask any questions that you may think of.

[parkplace33]

I would grade only the Mantle.

[G1911]

The 6 T218’s, the T220, the T68 Stonewall, the T205 Doolan, and the Willie Mays.

Though this would certainly be an unprofitable endeavor, those are the 10 coolest in my book.

[Rad_Hazard]

I would also only grade the Mantle.

[raulus]

Originally Posted by G1911

The 6 T218’s, the T220, the T68 Stonewall, the T205 Doolan, and the Willie Mays.

Though this would certainly be an unprofitable endeavor, those are the 10 coolest in my book.

The Mays doesn’t look to be all that pristine. Maybe a mid-grade item? If so, you can buy these in mid grade for pretty cheap, likely around the amount of the grading fees.

So I wouldn’t be inclined to grade this one.

[G1911]

Originally Posted by raulus

The Mays doesn’t look to be all that pristine. Maybe a mid-grade item? If so, you can buy these in mid grade for pretty cheap, likely around the amount of the grading fees.

So I wouldn’t be inclined to grade this one.

Hence, “unprofitable endeavor”

[raulus]

Originally Posted by G1911

Hence, “unprofitable endeavor”

Consider my comment withdrawn.

[TaxMechanick]

Mantle and Stonewall, that's it.

Glenn

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by raulus

The Mays doesn’t look to be all that pristine. Maybe a mid-grade item? If so, you can buy these in mid grade for pretty cheap, likely around the amount of the grading fees.

So I wouldn’t be inclined to grade this one.

The Mays is also not complete. The other half is missing so I wouldn't grade that one myself for this reason. I would search out a complete one instead and sell of this half at that time.




.

[RL]

only Mantle

[bmattioli]

If selling or for PC only the Mantle..

[npa589]

Not sure that you and I have even had a hint of an indirect or direct line of communication prior to this very moment, but clearly you are very predictable. I attempted to preempt a response such as this with the disclaimer of “not trying to cause a stir” knowing that there are some keyboard warriors here who are sated by online arguments of the most inane and pointless nature.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[BobC]

Originally Posted by npa589

Not sure that you and I have even had a hint of an indirect or direct line of communication prior to this very moment, but clearly you are very predictable. I attempted to preempt a response such as this with the disclaimer of “not trying to cause a stir” knowing that there are some keyboard warriors here who are sated by online arguments of the most inane and pointless nature.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What????????????


You said this thread had turned into a TPG bashing session........period. I'm merely asking you were did that come from, because no one said a word about or against TPGs in the thread. So answer the question!