Baseball Magazine supplements : 2017 different.

[doug.goodman]

I'm finally getting a chance to go thru my supplements. In case anybody cares, I now have 957 different m113 and m114 supplements in my collection, here are most of them :

https://www.flickr.com/photos/douggo...57692457124881

Always looking for more...

Doug

[ramram]

So Doug, I guess that monsterous scorecard collection wasn’t enough for you?

Rob M

[doug.goodman]

Ha! I still need to scan lots of those, too.

I just added the m113 supplements, and the 1957 posters, and a couple others.

957 different, now.

7 left to scan.

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

I'm finally getting a chance to go thru my supplements. In case anybody cares, here are 957 different m113 and m114 supplements that I have in my collection.

https://www.flickr.com/photos/douggo...57692457124881

Always looking for more...

Doug

Truly an epic collection, Doug! Wow!!

[pherbener]

Great stuff Doug!! That WaJo arm and 1915 Matty are two of my favorites!

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by pherbener

Great stuff Doug!! That WaJo arm and 1915 Matty are two of my favorites!

That arm might be my favorite, too.

[bigfanNY]

A very long time ago I picked up a hard coverd ledger that was used as a scrapbook. Inside was filied with baseball magazine photos taken from the inside covers. Period was mid 1930's full of classic Conlan images. Many of these same pictures were used for the premiums. I have always liked the large format premiums and have a Lajoie framed on my wall. Congrats on a great collection.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

A very long time ago I picked up a hard coverd ledger that was used as a scrapbook. Inside was filied with baseball magazine photos taken from the inside covers. Period was mid 1930's full of classic Conlan images. Many of these same pictures were used for the premiums. I have always liked the large format premiums and have a Lajoie framed on my wall. Congrats on a great collection.

Thank you.

There is another thread titled "Hobby terms that annoy you" on net54, one of the things that annoys me the most, although it doesn't really fit in that thread, is people who sell the inside cover pictures as "supplements".

But what can you do?

Received 4 new ones in the mail today, so up to 961 (which is really 968 once I get 7 more scans done).

Doug

[Boomer]

Incredible

[doug.goodman]

Got a completely new one today, thank you ebay.

Buhl now joins Joe Adcock as the only ones with the weird "cut and paste" when doing that involved actual glue.

This one is #1,101

[doug.goodman]

#1,102 showed up today. It's a variation of one that I already have, but it's still a pretty good one.

Doug

[bigfanNY]

Doug I saw that you ised Itoya portfolios to store / display your large format items. Last werkI I ordered 3 of different sizes 18x24, 14x17 , 8.5 x11 and I am very happy with them, and will order more this week. The largest is great for storing old Rock posters that have been rooled up in tubes in my closet for 40 years. ( damm I am getting old) the middle size holds a wide variety of items and will most likely be what I use most. The smaller is great for older scorecards. So just a shout out of thanks for the heads up.
J

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by bigfanNY

Doug I saw that you ised Itoya portfolios to store / display your large format items. Last werkI I ordered 3 of different sizes 18x24, 14x17 , 8.5 x11 and I am very happy with them, and will order more this week. The largest is great for storing old Rock posters that have been rooled up in tubes in my closet for 40 years. ( damm I am getting old) the middle size holds a wide variety of items and will most likely be what I use most. The smaller is great for older scorecards. So just a shout out of thanks for the heads up.
J

You're welcome.

[biggies]

Amazing collection Doug, Do you by chance have a pic of an offering or coupon page used to obtain these posters?

Thanks, Bob

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by biggies

Amazing collection Doug, Do you by chance have a pic of an offering or coupon page used to obtain these posters?

Thanks, Bob

Sorry, I do not. I have contemplated going through my Baseball Magazine collection to find all the ads and figure out if I can improve on the "catalog" but I haven't ever gotten around to it.

My offer to you for m113s is still open...

Doug

[BeanTown]

Wow!! Good stuff. Will have to look what I have burried away frm the old Hunt and Lipset auctions from decades ago.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by biggies

Do you by chance have a pic of an offering or coupon page used to obtain these posters?

Thanks, Bob

After Bob's question, I have done some digging and have started a new thread to discuss it :

https://www.net54baseball.com/showth...04#post2069004

[doug.goodman]

With special thanks to Wheatland Auctions and to Uncle Jimmy, I received two new team variations in the mail today.

Doug

[doug.goodman]

Picked up a font variation on the first of the three different Mantle photos used in the m114 set from ebay last week. Bummed that I missed out on a Cobb from the same seller. Oh well, on with the hunt...

[drumback]

Wow, what an amazing collection. Doug, I hope you never decide to break it up. No way it could ever be duplicated.

[Lucas00]

Wow, great collection. I love these even more the more I look at them. And even more to add to my list of Schoendienst items needed. Are any for sale?

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by Lucas00

Wow, great collection. I love these even more the more I look at them. And even more to add to my list of Schoendienst items needed. Are any for sale?

I got rid of my duplicates during the zombie apocalypse, sorry.

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

I got rid of my duplicates during the zombie apocalypse, sorry.

😢
Unfortunate

[akleinb611]

Not for me. I snagged most of them (after another collector purchased the entire lot, kept the best-condition pieces for himself, and sold the rest to me for a very reasonable price).

I have about 130 different ones on ebay right now.

Hoping to find some this year at the National...

[doug.goodman]

I bought a new Ruth caption variation on ebay yesterday, I'll post pix when it arrives.

This will be my 22nd different Ruth m114 (involving 7 different photos)

[Lucas00]

An auction listing you may want to take a look at doug.

https://memorylaneinc.com/site/bids/...e?itemid=77541

[doug.goodman]

Thank you for the heads up Lucas, I very much appreciate it.
Doug

[Lucas00]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

Thank you for the heads up Lucas, I very much appreciate it.
Doug

Of course Doug, Always share things I know people are looking for. Especially when they are a main obscure focus!

[doug.goodman]

With thanks to the most recent auction by The Collector Connection, I present to you Mr. Tris Speaker #1,334 in my m113 / m114 collection. There are three caption versions of this picture, as shown below.

[jason.1969]

Doug, forgive the spam if this is well known but I ran across this ad in the 11/17/1962 Sporting News.

Am wondering if these photos are the leftover M114 inventory of the recently defunct Baseball Magazine.




Jason
Twitter: @heavyj28

[doug.goodman]

Thank you Jason, but although everybody's favorite opinion seller likes to slab the Baseball Monthly m118s as being from Baseball Magazine they are actually a completely different issue. They are not related, as far as I know, and did not overlap in issue dates.

While not all Baseball Magazine supplements note the magazine, the vast majority do. (now I'm going to have to figure out how many, hahaha)

All Baseball monthly supplements note that magazine.

Here is my recently sold Mays and an original ad from Baseball Monthly.

[doug.goodman]

Today I added a new Gehrig to my collection. #11 of the "posed with bat" version, and #27 in total across his 4 different picture versions.

Also, a new Ruth, #7 for me of the "batting for Yankees" version, and #23 total across his 8 different picture versions.


I am DEEP into my study of m114 release dates, having gathered details from most of the ads in the magazines, and I've identified 211 different right side and 94 left side captions in my 1,379 m114 supplements.

Trying to channel my inner Jefferson Burdick when trying to determine the best way to note them in an updated catalog.

Open to any suggestions.

Doug

[akleinb611]

Glad you're continuing with your audit of all the dates of issue. Any luck finding the story behind the M113 Victor Saier?

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by akleinb611

Glad you're continuing with your audit of all the dates of issue. Any luck finding the story behind the M113 Victor Saier?

Mr. Saier was never mentioned in an advertisement for the posters (unless I have missed it, happy to be corrected), so that complicates things, but is probably part of why he is also not listed in the Standard Catalog as having a poster, even though he does.

Based on his career stats, and the captions in the picture of one of his posters that I received from you Alan, I put the release date as being after the 1913 season, but prior to Nov 1914.

[Lucas00]

That Death Valley nickname has to be one of the coolest I've ever heard in baseball, awesome!

[doug.goodman]

While scanning my new additions today, I realized that The Johnson Arm picture is cropped differently than my other versions, so it's not caption variation #3 of The Arm, but version #2 of The Arm. Note there is only 1 belt loop shown on his pants on this new version.

There was a time in my life when a hot chick in a bikini would get me excited, but I think picture variations being added to my m113 collection, especially ones previously unknown to me, get me way more excited these days.

[doug.goodman]

From the most recent LOTG auction, where I added 3 new m113s to my collection, this is the best one

[doug.goodman]

Updated scan to show the differences in these three versions.

[doug.goodman]

Finally getting close to finishing the resorting and relabeling of the Itoya folders that house my m114 collection.

[mikecala98]

Picked up a scrapbook full of these today. Will go through it later and snap some pics!

[puckpaul]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

While scanning my new additions today, I realized that The Johnson Arm picture is cropped differently than my other versions, so it's not caption variation #3 of The Arm, but version #2 of The Arm. Note there is only 1 belt loop shown on his pants on this new version.

There was a time in my life when a hot chick in a bikini would get me excited, but I think picture variations being added to my m113 collection, especially ones previously unknown to me, get me way more excited these days.

Hey Doug, great find on the Wajo.

Note that mine has the one belt loop and the baseball magazine on the right! A fourth version i guess.

[doug.goodman]

Nice one Paul. I'm currently in the process of trying to procure one of those single belt loop, right caption versions... I was going to wait until I succeeded to announce what will henceforth be known as the "Puck Variation".

Insert smiley face here.

Doug

[puckpaul]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

Nice one Paul. I'm currently in the process of trying to procure one of those single belt loop, right caption versions... I was going to wait until I succeeded to announce what will henceforth be known as the "Puck Variation".

Insert smiley face here.

Doug

lol. It’s one of the coolest photos around, if you cant find one i might have to part with it to enter “the collection”. It’s so weird that they tinkered with these so much and there are so many variations.

[doug.goodman]

Originally Posted by doug.goodman

Nice one Paul. I'm currently in the process of trying to procure one of those single belt loop, right caption versions... I was going to wait until I succeeded to announce what will henceforth be known as the "Puck Variation".

Insert smiley face here.

Doug

I received my "Puck Variation" Walter Johnson Arm m113 today.

I'm still interested in acquiring yours Paul.

[mikecala98]

[mikecala98]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[doug.goodman]

That's a cool scrapbook Mike, congrats. I just sent you a PM as there are a few that I would love to get from you.

[Schlesinj]

Wow, Neffs Pa, talk about a needle in a haystack.

[GoCubsGo32]

Incredible scrapbook! Congrats!

[doug.goodman]

With thanks to Scott Gaynor and his ebay store, I received my 117th m113 today. Extra special thanks for the careful shipping to avoid potential damage.

This Tris Speaker version, with him facing towards the left was released in Sept 1912. It was the first of two different pictures used for Speaker m113s, the other version has him... facing right.

I had it on my "might not exist" list due to never having seen one in my 20 years or so of looking.