1952 Mays Question

[rednecksims]

I have the honor of possibly purchasing this card, but I have a few questions. First I don't trust GA. Do you think it is fake or altered in any way? What do you think it would cross to with PSA?

Thanks
David

[Stonepony]

That card look fine to me

[bnorth]

I know nothing about the card. I would not buy any thing in a GA slab unless you have a rock solid return policy with enough time to send it in to PSA/SGC. I will say though I think their slabs are the best ever made by any company.

[rednecksims]

Originally Posted by bnorth

I know nothing about the card. I would not buy any thing in a GA slab unless you have a rock solid return policy with enough time to send it in to PSA/SGC. I will say though I think their slabs are the best ever made by any company.

That's what I was thinking and I think the guy would agree to it. Any idea what PSA might grade it at? That kind of determines what I'm willing to pay on it as it's not a cheap card (at least to me)

[rednecksims]

Originally Posted by Stonepony

That card look fine to me

Thanks. Any opinions on how it would grade?

[Stampsfan]

PSA 4

IMHO, as a guess.

[swarmee]

3.5-4 . Would have been a 4.5-5 without the scuff on his arm.

[rednecksims]

Thanks guys

[Leon]

I think a 2.5 to 3 on the grade....good luck

[rednecksims]

Thanks guys. He was a little heavy on the price and wouldn't budge. Couldn't pay $500 for a card that I would have to cross and can't see in person. He believed the price should have been a PSA 5 price.

[Paul S]

Originally Posted by rednecksims

Thanks guys. He was a little heavy on the price and wouldn't budge. Couldn't pay $500 for a card that I would have to cross and can't see in person. He believed the price should have been a PSA 5 price.

I can't see that. Besides the scuff (and any other flaws impossible to see in those images), that is a really nasty cut along the front-right border.