e107 Wagner vs e107 Matty

[honus94566]

Now the Matty is up in the current auction. It seems like the general consensus on here is that the Wagner went for maybe a little lower than expected, but still about right. The e107 common prices were low, probably due to the influx of inventory hitting the market.

Predictions for the Matty?

It's a beautiful card, no doubt about that.

[e107collector]

I still think the E107 Wagner SGC 50 went cheap. I understand that $125K is a lot of $$$, but I thought that card was going to go at least $175K. I wouldn't have been surprised if it went over $200K.

In my opinion, the Matty card should go for around $165K. It wouldn't surprise me if it went over $200K as well, because I really believe it's worth that much.

The Wagner & Matty E107's each have less than 10 examples known.

E107's seem to have a very thin collector base. If the "whales" don't need the card, who know where it will end up. Another factor is that there are a lot of E107's hitting the market in a short time frame.

I'll let the market decide, but these are just my opinions.

Tony

[sycks22]

I'm going with the Matty taking down the Wagner by a hair.

[joeadcock]

Originally Posted by e107collector

....Another factor is that there are a lot of E107's hitting the market in a short time frame.
Tony

Agreed and with other opinion above. It seems the E107 prices low by a bit, as many hitting at one time.

[terjung]

Completely agree with Tony's response above.

One of the best sets out there. The 1903 E107 Wagner is one of the most undervalued cards out there, IMO. I thought it went downright cheap!
With only 4 graded and less than 10 known, it is drastically more scarce than the T206 and is 6 years earlier. No debate as to whether it constitutes a "card" either.

The E107 Wagner and E107 Matty should be similarly valued.

[honus94566]

Originally Posted by e107collector

E107's seem to have a very thin collector base. If the "whales" don't need the card, who know where it will end up.
Tony

Originally Posted by terjung

The E107 Wagner and E107 Matty should be similarly valued.

Yep. It's definitely going to be interesting to see how it goes.

[g_vezina_c55]

Anyone can post the link of the Matty auction ?