cy young and nap lajoie

[toyman55]

would like some opinions on these two autographs. After much research I feel they are real.

cy young
and
nap lajoie

http://www.jpegbay.com/gallery-demo/512866.html

let me know your thoughts.

[canjond]

Both do not look good to me. I recall these being for sale on eBay - were they not?

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by toyman55

would like some opinions on these two autographs. After much research I feel they are real.

cy young
and
nap lajoie

http://www.jpegbay.com/gallery-demo/512866.html

let me know your thoughts.

Cy Young does not look good to me. The "Y" in Young looks like a the way he formed his "C" in Cy. Also, the "g" in Young does not appear to be right at all. The sequence of pen strokes is totally different than how he formed the top portion of the "g". Just my opinion, but I collect his signature. I can't comment on Nap Lajoie.
I hope you find this helpful!

[ss]

Neither Young nor Lajoie looks good to me.

[David Atkatz]

Both bad.

[toyman55]

I bought these on ebay 9 years ago. I am taking them to psa next weekend so I will let you know what they think. However I found a psa authenication on similar youngs and lajoies that match mine and intend to show them.

[GrayGhost]

Young looks real bad. Lajoie not as bad, but bad too.

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by toyman55

I bought these on ebay 9 years ago. I am taking them to psa next weekend so I will let you know what they think. However I found a psa authenication on similar youngs and lajoies that match mine and intend to show them.

and they'll show you the door....$225.00 poorer...bad decision.

[David Atkatz]

The fact of the matter is this:

Neither Cy Young nor Larry Lajoie signed those photos--regardless of what some bozo at PSA may or may not say now, or said in the past.