Ebay Fraud

[cmcclelland]

I am just seeking any guidance or experience that people might be able to pass along as I prepare to navigate the Ebay/Paypal buyer protection program for a recent purchase I made on ebay.

Here is what happened - I bought a 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 4 and Eddie Mathews PSA 3 (2 card lot in one transaction) on ebay last week for $11,750. I paid via Paypal immediately using my credit card. The package arrived today via UPS. I go to open it up and see that the bottom seem on the box is partially slit open and the box is creased and bent so that you can sort of see into the box. I could see bubble wrap and the box felt very light, so I instantly got this sinking feeling in my stomach. I opened the box and discovered what I worried would be the case - no cards inside. Just some bubble wrap with a crumpled up packing slip inside.

Based on my understanding, I should be fully protected under the Paypal Buyer Protection Plan. So, I've filed the claim with Paypal online tonight and will await their response. I've also left messages for the seller via email and telephone. His name is Scott Robert Mele from Troy, NY if anyone happens to know anything about him. His ebay id is srm128 - over 3000 transactions with 100% positive feedback. I've also filed a dispute on the charge with my credit card company.

I would just like to hear any stories as to other members' experiences with the Paypal Buyer Protection Program, especially on any larger transactions. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks.

Colt McClelland

[ullmandds]

how horrible...I hope you get this worked out!

[3and2]

Colt,

What an awful story. Keep us informed w/ the situation.

[Leon]

If you paid via your credit card, paypal or not, I feel a tad bit better. I wouldn't say you are out of the woods by any means but CC companies are usually pretty good. In my experience (at least with Bank of America) they really protect me. All I have to do is say boo, and they give me my money back. Keep us informed. What a horrible situation.....

[ChiefBenderForever]

I'm sure you will get your money back but would rather have the cards. What a nightmare. What about UPS and the driver? What is seller saying I'm sure he is going to have to file a claim, what a mess good luck.

[Jay Wolt]

Colt, your card looks like the one that Huggins & Scott recently auctioned of at $13,200.
You may want to contact them to see what they know.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll...=STRK:MEWAX:IT