T206 / T205 You Grade 'em - For Fun!

[bigtrain]

4.5,4.5.3.5

[E93]

4.5, 5, 3
JimB

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by E93

4.5, 5, 3
JimB

I'll second that. Agree with Jim.

[OnAT206Bender]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

I'll second that. Agree with Jim.

I think I would be happy with those grades! See soon

[OnAT206Bender]

Okay, so no one guessed exacly right, but three had the last two correct...

T206 Walter Johnson '5'
T206 Cobb - Green Background '4'
T205 Mathewson - '3'

That was good fun.....thanks!

I will post pics of the graded cards if anyone is interested.

[frankbmd]

I was one in at 4, 4, 3.

But I would consider Marty's 60, 50, 40 guess to be spot on.

Credit where credit is due, even if the Johnson was overgraded.

[OnAT206Bender]

Originally Posted by frankbmd

I was one in at 4, 4, 3.

But I would consider Marty's 60, 50, 40 guess to be spot on.

Credit where credit is due, even if the Johnson was overgraded.

Yup, you're right Frank, thanks for catching that

Great job, Marty!!!

Overgraded, undergraded...its all in the law of averages.

[freakhappy]

Originally Posted by frankbmd

I was one in at 4, 4, 3.

But I would consider Marty's 60, 50, 40 guess to be spot on.

Credit where credit is due, even if the Johnson was overgraded.

Did sgc grade these?