Impossible Ty Cobb autographed ball passed by JSA and PSA

[ss]

Quoting SeyHey: "I don't normally get involved in threads about the authenticity of autographs, because that is not my area of expertise. But, the response from Heritage so astounded me, that I had to reply...."

Totally agree with SeyHey. heritage should just acknlowledge it made a mistake, and corrected it as soon as they becam aware. Why lie when the truth sounds so much better?

[BrandonG]

Originally Posted by ss

Quoting SeyHey: "I don't normally get involved in threads about the authenticity of autographs, because that is not my area of expertise. But, the response from Heritage so astounded me, that I had to reply...."

Totally agree with SeyHey. heritage should just acknlowledge it made a mistake, and corrected it as soon as they becam aware. Why lie when the truth sounds so much better?

+1...Great post SeyHey. Here's the original description from Heritage. How the rest of you are defending Heritage, I don't know. This is pretty straight forward, had they said it was a mistake I would have said great, thanks for that, you guys are top notch.

When I read the below description, I think that PSA/DNA has looked at the item and authenticated it, not that it's a preview and maybe it will be authenticated maybe not.

[travrosty]

Originally Posted by BrandonG

+1...Great post SeyHey. Here's the original description from Heritage. How the rest of you are defending Heritage, I don't know. This is pretty straight forward, had they said it was a mistake I would have said great, thanks for that, you guys are top notch.

When I read the below description, I think that PSA/DNA has looked at the item and authenticated it, not that it's a preview and maybe it will be authenticated maybe not.

yes, you have to go with what they say, if they say full loa and auction loa, then that's it, and if they just said sorry instead of getting all testy, people would have respected that. as it is, they say they are only making the change because they didnt want any more posts misrepresenting what they are doing, but they still think what they are doing is no big deal. Thats the impression I got.

Why not say you are making the change because you realize that you shouldn't be giving impressions of authentication ahead of time no matter what the reason and it is the right thing to do.

[Leon]

Everyone really needs to read the rules. That being said if you said something in this thread that requires your full name to be in the post please put it there....thanks