About how would these cards grade?

[fkw]

Originally Posted by zljones

Thanks for all the input everyone. Looks like I paid a little too much for that Greenberg several months ago, it was listed as "Good" condition for $125, too much, o well live and I learned.

25 years ago your RAW R320 card was often called "Good", and the T205 Clarke would be G/VG or VG by many.

3rd party grading is very conservative on purpose, and IMO they leave no room at the bottom of their scale...

Years ago a Poor card was a destroyed card (ie torn in 1/2 taped back together, hole punches, skinned backs, no borders, etc. Fair was only slightly better.

Now with 3rd party grading, you can find nice clean (vintage) cards with anything from a 4-10 grade. Even many "1's" have nice eye appeal and should never have the word "POOR" associated with them...

ie.

VG IMO



I actually think they spin a wheel sometimes to get the number they put on the slab....