Fake 1933 All Star Program

[ibuysportsephemera]

Not doubting you at all...but how can you tell?

Jeff

[ruth-gehrig]

What's an authentic one worth that's been scored? I know an antique guy who has one but he hoards everything! It wouldn't be easy prying it away from him.

[Shoeless Moe]

Its missing the trademark on the scorecard page.

[ibuysportsephemera]

Thanks...I will watch for that in the future.

Jeff

[ctownboy]

It also looks like the seller could be increasing his Feed Back scores with the help from either himself, his relatives or his buddies.

Why I say this is because if you look at his FB, he has sold a lot of things to Pickinforalivin and another id with "pickin" in the name. All three live in the same area (Berea, Windsor and another small town) in Kentucky.

Finally, if the person sells baseball reprints, reproductions of scorecards and inflates their FB with help from friends, it wouldn't surprise me if they also shill bid their auctions.

David

[swarmee]

Originally Posted by ctownboy

It also looks like the seller could be increasing his Feed Back scores with the help from either himself, his relatives or his buddies.

Why I say this is because if you look at his FB, he has sold a lot of things to Pickinforalivin and another id with "pickin" in the name. All three live in the same area (Berea, Windsor and another small town) in Kentucky.

However, that's kind of moronic, since eBay only counts the first positive feedback for you from any buyer in your number. Every other positive feedback does not show in the feedback number. If someone is making lots of cheap auctions just to increase their five star rating, that's pretty sad.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by ruth-gehrig

What's an authentic one worth that's been scored? I know an antique guy who has one but he hoards everything! It wouldn't be easy prying it away from him.

I'm no expert but I've seen scored ones go from 800-1500 depending on condition and where it is being sold, ebay vs auction house.