Trimmed Card Crossover

[bobbyw8469]

BOTH companies have made their share of mistakes. If PSA has made more mistakes than SGC, it is mainly because they grade more cards than SGC. One company is not more apt to grade trimmed cards than the other (sorry SGC lovers!)......

[Matt]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

BOTH companies have made their share of mistakes. If PSA has made more mistakes than SGC, it is mainly because they grade more cards than SGC. One company is not more apt to grade trimmed cards than the other (sorry SGC lovers!)......

I disagree; PSA has made embarrasing mistakes with trimmed cards - an OJ comes to mind where the whole ad bottom was trimmed and they gave it a 5. And, on topic, just browsing newly listed on eBay:
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1921-E220-PS...item336c023d58

[bobbyw8469]

I can post several pics of SGC mistakes that THEY have made. And I can promise that they grade less cards. It wouldn't surprised me that the percentage of goofs to cards graded is actually HIGHER with SGC!

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

I can post several pics of SGC mistakes that THEY have made.

No need to post several. Just post one. Let's see it (and I'm not talking about Bobby Jones).

[Brendan]

I thought these two images he posted awhile back were interesting.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by Brendan

I thought these two images he posted awhile back were interesting.

Ahh, there it is. I said Bobby Jones, but I meant Walter Hagen. That doesn't prove anything. It could have been microtrimmed after it was removed from the SGC holder. Show a card that resides in an SGC holder that has been significantly overgraded. Bet you can't do it.

[Brendan]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Ahh, there it is. I said Bobby Jones, but I meant Walter Hagen. That doesn't prove anything. It could have been microtrimmed after it was removed from the SGC holder. Show a card that resides in an SGC holder that has been significantly overgraded. Bet you can't do it.

Some might say that card I posted was significantly undergraded. (if it wasn't trimmed) Anyway, it isn't my argument and personally I like SGC better because I really can't stand PSA's holders.