Are you more likely to get a good deal on...

[mintacular]

an eBay BIN (or BIN B/O) or via an auction-style listing? Thanks for your opinion.

[Leon]

Hard to say.... I think if you can get to a BIN quickly you might get a better deal that way.

[rainier2004]

those auctions that end in the middle of the day can be pretty nice...

[Robextend]

Originally Posted by rainier2004

those auctions that end in the middle of the day can be pretty nice...

+1

[Vol]

Originally Posted by rainier2004

those auctions that end in the middle of the day can be pretty nice...

+2

[Piratedogcardshows]

I have gotten some great deals on both but if I had to choose definately Auction Style in my experiences.

[brob28]

I'd say auction style, but you have to have patience waiting for the right auction. Sometimes bidders get stupid on ya!

[Zach Wheat]

Originally Posted by rainier2004

those auctions that end in the middle of the day can be pretty nice...

+2 here....or end at weird times (like 3 AM ET) or in the middle of the day during a holiday weekend.

[Brendan]

It really matters what the card is. If it's a T206, Goudey or something common like that, you'd have a very hard time getting a deal in an auction style listing. But for something not as popular such as 1933 Uncle Jack's Candy, you're likely to get a better deal in an auction unless there is a bidding war.

[nebboy]

Originally Posted by Brendan

It really matters what the card is. If it's a T206, Goudey or something common like that, you'd have a very hard time getting a deal in an auction style listing. But for something not as popular such as 1933 Uncle Jack's Candy, you're likely to get a better deal in an auction unless there is a bidding war.

+1