Upgrades, Downgrades & What the !@#$#$%

[scooter729]

This card of mine is perfect for this - I have no idea why this got a 2, but I cracked and re-subbed to PSA and they were consistent with the 2. Anyone with any guesses?

[DixieBaseball]

Originally Posted by scooter729

This card of mine is perfect for this - I have no idea why this got a 2, but I cracked and re-subbed to PSA and they were consistent with the 2. Anyone with any guesses?

Scott - My guess would be very small paper loss or possible eraser marks. PSA will give you the reason if you ask them.

Beautiful card!

[Bridwell]

My guess is that it has a very slight glue residue on the back somewhere. You might have to take it out of the case and feel the back with your fingers to find it. It is a beautiful card.

[teetwoohsix]

Tony & Scott-

That's a shame.........no way those should've been graded 2's.

Beautiful cards !!

Sincerely, Clayton

[Doug]

I just got these three cards in the mail today and they don't seem to match their grades at all. I haven't submitted anything to PSA in years, but it seemed like you used to be able to specify "no qualifiers" so on a card that would have graded a PSA 7 (OC) due to VG centering they would just give it an unqualified PSA 3 instead. Maybe that's what happened with these?

[xdrx]

Originally Posted by NashvilleBaseball

Scott - My guess would be very small paper loss or possible eraser marks. PSA will give you the reason if you ask them.

Beautiful card!

Does SGC provide reasons as well? I shot an email off to them 10 days ago after getting some cards graded and haven't had any response at all.

[jcmtiger]

Leon, as a Ty Cobb collector I am jealous, that is a Great Card!!!

Joe

[Leon]

Originally Posted by jcmtiger

Leon, as a Ty Cobb collector I am jealous, that is a Great Card!!!

Joe

Thanks Joe. Short story on the T205 Cobby. The first time I posted it, right after I got it, a good hobby friend called me and asked me how much it was? I said it isn't for sale. He said, but you don't collect cards like that? I said, I know but I have always wanted that card, but only one that fit my standards for what I thought that card should look like AND was within my meager price range. As I said before in a poll about T205's, I just think that Cobby is the epitome of what a T205 should be. Anyone that doesn't think these cards are a form of art need look no further. And here is a Chase that was graded correctly....

[3-2-count]

Leon that Chase card is fantastic!! Bet it even looks prettier in person.....

[old-baseball]

If these are SGC NM 84's....



.... what's wrong with these?