cracked cards on psa pop reports and registry?

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by novakjr

Exactly how accurate is the PSA pop report?

Not very accurate. Then again, neither is SGC's.

Originally Posted by novakjr

Are the companies in contact with each other in regards to cards that have been crossed over so they can take the serial numbers out of their systems?

No, the companies do not share that information.

Originally Posted by novakjr

Or hypothetically, in John's case.. If he still had the original PSA flip after cracking and submitting to SGC and then back to PSA. Could he technically still use the original flip(or at least numbers) and have a 4 on his registry, despite the fact that the same card is currently holdered a 3?

Yes, he could list it on the registry as a 4 even though it doesn't exist. PSA has no way of knowing the card doesn't exist. About 4-5 years ago just for fun, I added the Gretzky/McNall Wagner to my T206 HOF registry. At the time the card didn't reside in any other registry so the system took it. I forgot about it and it stayed there for a long time until I sold the cards and deleted the registry.

One other thing, some people send the flips in to the grading company and I think they will remove them from the pop report then.