What Cards In Your Collection Would You Never Sell or Upgrade?

[3-2-count]

Although they're not the most valuable pieces in my collection I couldn't see myself parting with these (3). I don't think they could be replaced regardless of what grade the slab states.

[Rob D.]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

Although they're not the most valuable pieces in my collection I couldn't see myself parting with these (3). I don't think they could be replaced regardless of what grade the slab states.

When I saw that you had posted, Tony, I just knew the Lajoie would be included. Damn it.

[3-2-count]

Originally Posted by Rob D.

When I saw that you had posted, Tony, I just knew the Lajoie would be included. Damn it.

I even tried to hide it by adding a couple other cards in the scan along with it. Dammit Rob you still spotted it........

[DeanH3]

[3-2-count]

Great looking green Cobby Dean...........

[rainier2004]

I wouldn't sell my cards that came to me as a kid. I bought the 86 fleer baskerball set, borrowing money from my accountant father, sold the set and kept the jordan...it wont go up for sale. Also I have the fist card i ever bought still, a 59t musial, and that will never be sold. Mt father gave a 69 mantle in nrmt 20 yrs ago and that will never be sold. To say I'd sell for the right price is kind of pointless b/c who would offer me an ungodly pile of cheese for these cards? But every time i look at them i remember when, where, how and WHY i got them. There is a feeling that goes w/ that...you can bury those cards w/ me.

[joeadcock]

Wouldn't sell my T206 Lajoie my dad bought for me for $1 at a Flea Market in about 1975.

[milkit1]

hERES A COUPLE iM PRETTY SURE iLL NEVER SELL

33 goudey maranville signed.jpg

33 goudey welch.JPG

m116 brown front.jpg

[baseballcardfan1977]

Mine is not a card it's a signed Nolan Ryan Ball the first thing baseball related my daddy ever gave me. I don't care if I'm on the street starving I will have that ball in my ragged coat pocket or shopping cart.

[DeanH3]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

Great looking green Cobby Dean...........

Thanks Tony...extremely hard to see glue residue on the back is only reason for the harsh grade. No way I could replace it with the same eye appeal without breaking the bank.

[lutherlafy]

I hope I can keep these cards for many more years.

[itjclarke]

My top one is not a card, but a multi signed ball my dad got when he was 12 yrs old at an Enid Giants/Joplin Minors game in Oklahoma. Sweet spot is signed by the local idol, an 18 year old shortstop- Mickey Mantle, who I think made 60+ errors, but hit .383 that year.

These two are definitely not the most valuable, and have little on others posted, but took me a long time to find, and love them both for that... (also- all cards given/acquired in some way through my parents are off limits, but it would be boring to scan a 1987 Fleer Will Clark).

BTW- Curious how is that T206 Johnson only a 3, and the green Cobb only a 2? Rear paper loss?

[bcbgcbrcb]

Hey, Gary:

Great choice on the c1915 Ruth RPPC. I was disappointed to see how cheap it went when you won it in a recent auction (it was my consignment) but I'm glad that at least it went to a fellow collector who appreciates it so much.

[CubsFanCurt]

I have two that fit in here. When I started collecting in the early 80's I saw a picture of a '56 Ernie Banks card and that became my goal. I was all smiles when I bought that one. Almost 30 years after that I had a near fatal accident at work and eventually reached a modest settlement. The first thing I bought was a Banks rookie and the second thing was a Banks jersey.

I met Ernie Banks a few months after buying the card and told him what had happened to me. He had a shocked look on his face and asked if I was OK ( I am). I told him about my purchases and showed him the jersey I was wearing and he asked me if I'd take it off so he could sign it. The event organizers tried to jump in and say he couldn't sign it and I'll never forget what he said and did. He got mad at them and was almost yelling as he said "You all back off! This man was hurt and almost died! I want to sign his jersey and I'm GOING TO SIGN HIS JERSEY! You all need to learn what life is about." I was awestruck. I called my dad after that and we both had tears over what Ernie did. He is a real class act.

Here I am all wide eyed like a little kid at the event

[Leon]

Originally Posted by CubsFanCurt

I have two that fit in here. When I started collecting in the early 80's I saw a picture of a '56 Ernie Banks card and that became my goal. I was all smiles when I bought that one. Almost 30 years after that I had a near fatal accident at work and eventually reached a modest settlement. The first thing I bought was a Banks rookie and the second thing was a Banks jersey.

I met Ernie Banks a few months after buying the card and told him what had happened to me. He had a shocked look on his face and asked if I was OK ( I am). I told him about my purchases and showed him the jersey I was wearing and he asked me if I'd take it off so he could sign it. The event organizers tried to jump in and say he couldn't sign it and I'll never forget what he said and did. He got mad at them and was almost yelling as he said "You all back off! This man was hurt and almost died! I want to sign his jersey and I'm GOING TO SIGN HIS JERSEY! You all need to learn what life is about." I was awestruck. I called my dad after that and we both had tears over what Ernie did. He is a real class act.

Here I am all wide eyed like a little kid at the event

Great story about Banks.Those kinds of stories restore some of my faith in mankind and sports celebrities in particular. Glad you are ok after the accident.

As for the topic, I am with Adam, I think. Nothing is 100% off limits. I think at some point I would like to do a catalog to sell my collection. Not sure when but I think that would be a lot of fun. Nice thread too!!

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

I even tried to hide it by adding a couple other cards in the scan along with it. Dammit Rob you still spotted it........

Tony,
He wasn't the only one who spotted it!! I have loved that card since the day I first saw your post with it!!

[3-2-count]

Thank you for the kind words Greg.

[T206Collector]

Really every card in my signed T206 collection, unless I have doubles. It is easy to fall in love with the Hall of Famers, like Fred Clarke, Cy Young and Walter Johnson. But my favorite autographed T206 card may just be my Lena Blackburne. I really just love the signature and overall presentation. Also, it is hard not to love Fred Snodgrass' comments about how he was once a catcher; my first autographed T206 card (Marquard portrait); or the highest graded signed T206 card (Doyle portrait) I have ever seen. The Clarke and Doyle are originally from the Jeff Morey collection, which I view as the best provenance imaginable.

[benchod]

Beautiful cards, Paul

[U240robert]

Originally Posted by 3-2-count

Although they're not the most valuable pieces in my collection I couldn't see myself parting with these (3). I don't think they could be replaced regardless of what grade the slab states.

For PSA 3-4
those are very nice looking cards !

Robert

[3-2-count]

Thank you Robert. Very much appreciated......

[Clutch-Hitter]

Awesome Calvindog and Tony!
______________

It was around this time, collecting early to mid-eighties, that I asked my friend while we walked to our little league park if he thought there was any such thing as a real Babe Ruth card from his playing days. He, nor anyone else, knew if there was or not. Used to imagine what one would look like, with my template being black and white, some sort of action shot maybe.

So now, nearly thirty years later, I have a few. So this 80's card means a lot for a few reasons. A true entertainer on the mound with the Braves, stomping, raging behind the mound, finally delivering that 88 MPH puss.......The Mad Hungarian error card; It was a fairly big deal back then:

[GrayGhost]

Great thread, w lots of GREAT cards and stories. My favorite two stories are the 52 Mantle dad pulled out of the pack back in the day, and the Ernie Banks story.

Far as the cards you have all shared, too many greats and rarities to single one out.

[Cat]

A few years ago we had a thread like this and I posted an N162 Anson that would NEVER leave my collection. Within 18 months it was gone. Today, I would say, this card will likely remain for a long time. I like the card and wouldn't want to spend the money for an upgrade, if one ever came available.

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by Cat

A few years ago we had a thread like this and I posted an N162 Anson that would NEVER leave my collection. Within 18 months it was gone. Today, I would say, this card will likely remain for a long time. I like the card and wouldn't want to spend the money for an upgrade, if one ever came available.

Upgrading a card that nice would be nearly impossible anyway! Wow thanks for showing it!

[e107collector]

That is a great looking card! Previously Andy Baran's? Thanks for showing.

Tony

P.S. - Did you ever think of getting it reholdered by SGC? There seems to be a bigger gap than usual on the black insert. I'd be afraid that it would damage the border of the card. Just my opinion.