Building a Set... Which Way to Cross?

[familytoad]

I voted for SGC...look at the Young and the Tinker...both low grade and to me that baggie looks awful! Tinker looks quite nice.
(Evers would look much better in the sgc black slab too)

[cozmokramer]

Originally Posted by familytoad

I voted for SGC...look at the Young and the Tinker...both low grade and to me that baggie looks awful! Tinker looks quite nice.
(Evers would look much better in the sgc black slab too)

Well the Young Sweeney and Evers would have to be re-cased by PSA if I went that way anyway. Notice the label is their old designation for the set.

The Barry Bescher and Donovan were recently graded by PSA, so I would expect the baggie in the Young to be history if resent to PSA anyway.

[cozmokramer]

Any differences in the registry? Does it make more sense to have them all on one vs the other?

[ValKehl]

Hi Eric - I voted for SGC because, IMHO, the cards will display much nicer in the SGC holders, especially on an office wall.
Val

[Leon]

I voted leave them alone, and then read your post about displaying them. If you really want to display them in all the same holders the decision would be easy for me. I would go with SGC, if choosing between them and PSA. SGC slabs look better and they are better graders, imo. For those cards I would even say they might be a small bit more valuable in SGC holders than PSA ones.

[alanu]

I voted leave them alone, unless you want to put them in one of the set registries