Super Rare Ty Cobb Tango Egg, the Myth

[Leon]

Originally Posted by chaddurbin

funny that psa would take a stand with this card, with all the examples wonka showed above.

i hope it sold for cheaper raw because psa rejected it lol

What I was told is what folks said above.....PSA (Joe) thought the card could crumble in the authentication process and that is why they wouldn't do it. After seeing John's comparison of backs above it would be hard to think this is a faked card. Neat find.

[martyp]

Originally Posted by Leon

What I was told is what folks said above.....PSA (Joe) thought the card could crumble in the authentication process and that is why they wouldn't do it. After seeing John's comparison of backs above it would be hard to think this is a faked card. Neat find.

Leon, that is sure not the impression that I got from your first post. I had the impression that you felt that PSA was casting doubts on the card. That may not have been what you meant, but it appears that you had knowledge of some information and choose not to include it to give an implied opinion.

PSA wouldn't slab it and.....

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hey David
That is a great card but call me Mr. Skeptical. Not sure the fact that Joe O said they wouldn't slab it has any bearing on my thoughts but I just don't know about it. If it's real it's a really neat card. Thanks for posting and best regards
__________________
Leon Luckey

[Leon]

Originally Posted by martyp

Leon, that is sure not the impression that I got from your first post. I had the impression that you felt that PSA was casting doubts on the card. That may not have been what you meant, but it appears that you had knowledge of some information and choose not to include it to give an implied opinion.

PSA wouldn't slab it and.....

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hey David
That is a great card but call me Mr. Skeptical. Not sure the fact that Joe O said they wouldn't slab it has any bearing on my thoughts but I just don't know about it. If it's real it's a really neat card. Thanks for posting and best regards
__________________
Leon Luckey

Marty- I used my wording carefully. In the back of my mind I didn't see how slabbing that card would make it crumble. After the posts here it does seem as though that is a concern amongst grading companies.